HOT TOPICS ▶ Climate Change     Undoing The New Deal     The Real Baltimore     Reality Asserts Itself     United Kingdom    

  January 11, 2018

Trump's Medicaid Work Requirements Punish the Poor

The Trump administration has told states they can cut off Medicaid benefits unless recipients meet work requirements. Michael Lighty of National Nurses United calls it an "authoritarian social engineering project" that targets the most vulnerable
Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here

Share to Facebook Share to Twitter

The reason I continue to support TRNN is, not only is it real, it is also the most truthful. - Dick S
Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


Michael Lighty is the Director of Public Policy for National Nurses United and the California Nurses Association. Michael is also a Fellow at the Sanders Institute. He has served on the Oakland Planning Commission, and on community, education and political organizations' boards of directors. He was the first openly LGBTQ Commissioner for the Port of Oakland.


AARON MATÉ: It's The Real News, I'm Aaron Maté. The Trump administration has already threatened the healthcare of millions of people with its attacks on Obamacare, and now it's going after more. The administration has issued a guidance that tells states they can cut off Medicaid benefits unless recipients meet work requirements. It's the first time in Medicaid's 50-plus years that this guidance has gone into effect. Michael Lighty is Director of Public Policy for National Nurses United. Welcome, Michael. Let's start with what exactly this guidance is. What has the Trump White House told the states?

MICHAEL LIGHTY: Well, the Trump White House has told the states you can require people who receive Medicaid health benefits to work as a condition for receiving those benefits, effectively turning Medicaid into something it has never been, which is a welfare program. And it's a fundamental change to its design and approach.

AARON MATÉ: So what does now someone who's on Medicaid in one of these states - I believe the first state might be Kentucky - what does someone on Medicaid who currently is not working face in their daily life as a result of this?

MICHAEL LIGHTY: Well, they face -- in addition to whatever health challenges they also experience, which of course, that Medicaid population tends to have more chronic conditions -- higher health needs because in this country social and economic factors are the largest determinants of health status. And so a low-income population, which Medicaid is, is by nature of the inequality and injustice in this society, going to be less healthy. So they will confront those challenges first of all.

And then secondly, as we know there's a great disconnect between where many poor people live and where the jobs are, so they'll face massive transportation and logistics obstacles to getting employment. The first thing they'll face is a threat from the state of Kentucky or other states who say unless you're able to secure employment by X date, you will lose your healthcare coverage. I mean this is a self-defeating approach, because, of course, these less healthy people will become even less healthy. How are they going to be employed, if they are even in worse shape in terms of their health? So it's quite problematic in terms of the barriers set up. And we know about healthcare, Aaron, is that we know the more barriers you set up that are financial, logistical, cultural; those barriers will determine, ultimately, health status that can cost people their lives.

AARON MATÉ: So Michael, the official overseeing all this is Seema Verma, and Verma gave a speech a few months ago previewing this plan. And this is what she said:

SEEMA VERMA: Believing that community engagement requirements do not support or promote the objectives of Medicaid is a tragic example of the soft bigotry of low expectations consistently espoused by the prior administration. Those days are over.

AARON MATÉ: So that's Seema Verma, the head of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Michael, if you could respond to that, her saying that the days of "the soft bigotry of low expectations" are over.

MICHAEL LIGHTY: Yes. And they're being replaced by an authoritarian top-down approach that will eviscerate social safety-net programs and put people in the streets. And that is, I think, best exemplified by both their attack on Medicaid, which disabled folks realized was a direct threat to their lives and therefore protested against them. And the only bigotry going on here, Aaron, is the bigotry of an administration that says poor people do not deserve the same standard of care as others. And so, if you're poor, new requirements will be imposed. You will have to work. You will only be able to go to certain doctors. That's what so much of Medicaid is in the state of Indiana where the CMS administrator comes from. There have been huge profit gouging by private insurers. So the kind of bigotry that this policy reflects is discrimination against people in favor of insurance company and corporate profits.

And their view is essentially, they want to social engineer people's access to health. And so again, what we have rather than low expectations, we have a authoritarian social engineering project to say that these are the people who must be singled out and required to "engage in their community" as a condition of having healthcare. It's the exact opposite. Do we say that in order to have fire services, if you live in a poor neighborhood, you have to go to work? Healthcare is a public good. It's not a program based upon the social engineering dictates of an authoritarian government who wants to impose its will on the states, and that's what this policy represents.

AARON MATÉ: So Michael, I noted in my intro that this is the first time in Medicaid's more than 50 years of being in existence that there has been this work requirement imposed, but it's not the first time in the history of U.S. federal assistance that work requirements have been mandated. And the major case was in the mid-'90s when President Clinton, a Democrat, signed work requirements as a part of so-called welfare reform. So I'm wondering, can we not just be blaming Trump here, but did Clinton's move, endorsed by many Democrats working with Republicans, was that a predicate for this move today?

MICHAEL LIGHTY: Certainly, it is. It has to be understood as that, Aaron. And the problem is that Medicaid is not a welfare program; it's a healthcare program. And it's a program that is jointly paid for and administrated by the states and the federal government under the Affordable Care Act, a huge expansion of the federal contribution. So it's really, in that sense, it's different.

Now, on the other hand, the kind of work requirements that are imposed in AFDC [Aid to Families with Dependent Children] have been completely counterproductive in many cases because the same is true for those folks as it is for many on Medicaid, is that the barriers to employment are not individual; they're structural, they're social. And so to impose a requirement to overcome barriers that are actually not under an individual's control is a kind of neoliberal social engineering that was reflected in the Clinton administration's so-called welfare reform and in this this Medicaid work requirement. Though again, it is an escalation of that trend because it's turning Medicaid into something it's not, and it also is jeopardizing people's health status and lives just as the other cuts jeopardize their access to food and shelter.

So you do see commonalities and you also see the difference, and what we can, I think, speculate as well is that this attempt to taint Medicaid, in a sense, by saying that it's going to people who are undeserving, and until they prove they're deserving by doing community engagement we're not going to give them any benefits, that mentality is in direct counter-position to the general support that people felt toward Medicaid as a result of their greater awareness of the role that it plays in seniors' and the lives of disabled folks.

Most of the spending on Medicaid is devoted to seniors and the disabled. Most of the people in Medicaid are children. I think there's a ... When the CMS administrator refers to "soft bigotry of low expectations," I think she's being bigoted in the sense that she's assuming that that Medicaid population is of a certain demographic, and in fact, most Medicaid recipients are white. And I think that this is an attempt to undermine Medicaid, characterizing it as a welfare program for the undeserving poor until they prove they're worthy, and that dynamic is destructive socially and really is intended to undermine support for Medicaid, I think.

AARON MATÉ: We'll leave it there. Michael Lighty, Director of Public Policy for National Nurses United. Thank you.

MICHAEL LIGHTY: Thanks a lot, Aaron.

AARON MATÉ: And thank you for joining us on The Real News.


Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at

latest stories

Trump Boasts of Killer Arms Sales in Meeting with Saudi Dictator, Using Cartoonish Charts
15 Years of Mass Destruction in Iraq
Mercer's Cambridge Analytica 'Utterly Sleazy'
Duterte's Bloody War on Philippines' Leftists
Former Venezuelan Interior Minister Arrested: Fracturing the Bolivarian Movement?
Democracy in Crisis: Take Note
Meet The Man Behind Cambridge Analytica, Who Made Trump President
Will Congress Affirm its Constitutional Power to Stop the War in Yemen?
A Rare Glimpse Inside a Police Body-Camera Review Unit
In Afrin the Turks are Looting and Pillaging with Gunfire
Protester Arrested At State House: Gov. Hogan Would Not Drink Water Contaminated by Fracking
'Samantha Em-Powers Genocide in Yemen': Students Protest US Role in Saudi War
After a Shooting at His School, a Maryland Teacher Speaks Out
European Left Divided Over Brexit
Marilyn Mosby: From Freddie Gray to GTTF
Trump and the Rise of the European Right, with Reps of UK Labour Party, De Linke, Podemos, and Syriza
Petroleum Executives Visit Trump, Increasing Offshore Oil Drilling
EPA Sued for Removing Independent Scientists from its Advisory Board
Inequality in America: A National Town Hall
Laura Flanders Show: Women's History Makes The Future
Corbyn Allies in Labour Attacked For Supporting Palestinian Struggle
Paul Jay: Threats facing Humanity, Russiagate & the Role of Independent Media
Kochs and ALEC Behind Criminalization of Dissent Bills in Five States
West's Anti-Russian Fervor Will Help Putin Win Election On Sunday
Stephen Hawking: Fighter for Progressive Politics
Corbyn Smeared as 'Russian Stooge' for Requesting Evidence on Poisoned Spy
Chief in Charge of Internal Affairs To Retire from Baltimore Police
Corbyn Calls for Evidence in Escalating Poison Row
Sanders Resolution Against War in Yemen Challenged by Mattis
Senate Expands 'Lobbyist Bill' to Deregulate Real Estate,, The Real News Network, Real News Network, The Real News, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of Independent World Television inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and The Real News Network.

All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network. Click here for more

Problems with this site? Please let us know

Web Design, Web Development and Managed Hosting