Krugman and Obama’s Dangerous Austerity Myths
NO ADVERTISING, GOVERNMENT OR CORPORATE FUNDING
DONATE TODAY
 $115,248


  January 13, 2013

Krugman and Obama’s Dangerous Austerity Myths


Bill Black: Obama nominates a Wall St. loyalist to help negotiate the "Grand Betrayal"
Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here
   



audio

Share to Facebook Share to Twitter



"The Real News Network" delivers as the title indicates -"Real News". Not news cycle trash or fluff. - Laviero
Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


transcript

Krugman and Obama’s Dangerous Austerity MythsPAUL JAY, SENIOR EDITOR, TRNN: Welcome to The Real News Network. I'm Paul Jay in Baltimore. And welcome to this week's edition of The Black Financial and Fraud Report with Bill Black, who now joins us.

Bill is associate professor of economics and law at University of Missouri–Kansas City. He's a white-collar criminologist, a former financial regulator. And he's the author of The Best Way to Rob a Bank Is to Own One.

Thanks for joining us again, Bill.

BILL BLACK, ASSOC. PROF. ECONOMICS AND LAW, UMKC: Thank you.

JAY: What are you working on this week?

BLACK: Well, the odd convergence of Paul Krugman and President Obama. And so on the same day, they put out these odes to austerity that in the one case is ironic, because if Obama had gotten his way, he would have crushed his reelection opportunities, along with the U.S. economy, and the second, because Krugman has been fighting against austerity all these months.

So the first one is a Krugman column. And what he mostly wants to say is things like, you know, print the platinum $1 trillion and such. And he has a throwaway paragraph that says, you know, if you folks really want to deal with the budget deficit, if that's your issue, well, then there's a simple way to do that: you just raise taxes and cut spending. But elections have consequences and, you know, you don't always get that which you wish.

And then President Obama, in connection with Treasury Secretary Geithner leaving and nominating Jacob Lew to take that position, said something very similar. He said, hey, Geithner's the greatest Treasury secretary in modern times because he's produced 6 million new jobs, and now we're starting to reduce the deficit through a combination of taxes and government spending.

So let's go back to Krugman for a second. We're in a great recession and a weak recovery from it, in which unemployment is still twice as high as it should be, in which long-term unemployment is at record levels, in which poverty is at record levels, use of food stamps is at record levels. We have a jobs crisis and an inequality crisis.

But of course that's not what is good for the politics of all of these things. So President Obama wants to take credit for the creation of the jobs, which comes from the weak recovery. And then he wants to switch to his real love, which is the talking about deficit reduction. And that's the transition to Lew. And he says Lew is the guy that presided over three years of balanced budgets with Clinton, and he's going to be the guy to, you know, basically put austerity into force, full force, in the United States, and then all will be well.

Now, this is incredibly odd in the—start with Krugman, because Krugman has been writing for years about how austerity is not a simple matter, that in fact if what we did was raise taxes and cut spending, what we would do is cut private-sector demand by raising taxes, and then we would cut public sector demand by cutting spending [snip] would indirectly, since most government spending goes to the private sector, then also reduce private-sector demand. And the reason you have a recession is that demand is already inadequate. And this is not just any recession; this is the Great Recession, where demand was inadequate by trillions of dollars—and a trillion is a thousand billion, right?

So the stimulus program, everybody knew, was nowhere remotely big enough to replace the lost demand. But Krugman has been saying, don't do austerity, don't do austerity, that's the path that has pushed the Eurozone into recession into recession and put Spain, Italy, and Greece into Great Depression levels of unemployment, so don't go that route. It isn't simple. If you increase taxes, if you cut spending at this period, it will not cure the economy. It's just the opposite. It's more like medical malpractice in the old days of bleeding the patient. And then, because it doesn't, of course, help them recover, you bleed them more. And you do this until you cause an economic disaster.

So Krugman's completely off base if you quote Krugman on Krugman. And it's very strange.

Then you get to Obama. And what Obama doesn't realize is Geithner, of course, is the guy that pushed to kill stimulus. He is the guy that fought very hard not to create those 6 million jobs. If Geithner has gotten his way—and Geithner's famous quotation is that stimulus doesn't do anything for you, that it's like sugar: you just get a short-term high, and then, you know, you're cranky and rebellious and such and nothing gets done.

So had Obama listened to Geithner in the earliest months of the administration, Obama would have already been out of a job, because he would have thrown us back into a deep recession using austerity, and, of course, the Republicans would have control of the Senate.

Then Geithner tries to do it again in July 2011. This is what they refer to as the grand bargain—what I refer to as the grand betrayal—where they deliberately sought to cut the safety net—Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food stamps—where they sought to slash well over $1 trillion in public spending over the decade and raise taxes.

Had Geithner and Lew [incompr.] two, three principal aides pushing this—the third was a guy named Bill Daley, who was [incompr.] and Peterson is the guy that wants Social [Security privatized so that] Wall Street can make a fortune [snip] fees of our retirement accounts. These three aides—and they were the top aides for Obama on these negotiations back in July 2011—tried very hard to impose austerity. At the time, unemployment was 9.1 percent. This is, again, July 2011. Had they succeeded in getting austerity, the country would have gone back into recession within a few months, unemployment would have been well above 10 percent, quite possibly above 11 percent—European levels, in other words—and it would have been increasing every month during 2012, their election year. Hence Obama would have been destroyed politically and the Democrats would have lost the Senate. So that's the second time Geithner and Lew combined to try to create the grand betrayal and would have had the ironic effect of defeating Obama.

The third was after, despite himself, he gets reelected, Geithner tries the same thing, and with the support of Lew, where they go and they tell the president, we should, even though we don't have to, make deep concessions on spending cuts and on the safety net. And, fortunately, Senate Majority Leader Reed was so outraged, he took the proposal and threw it into his fireplace, into the fire, the raging fire in his fireplace, and burned it up. So we dodged the bullet again.

But now the president is signalling that's what Lew is going to try to do to the nation again. And so all the emphasis is now we need to start cutting spending even more, we need to raise taxes even more. And we can all look at what this has done to Europe and the devastation. But apparently the president and his principal advisers can't see that. And now it looks like even Krugman has become deeply clouded.

JAY: Thanks for joining us, Bill.

BLACK: Thank you.

JAY: And thank you for joining us on The Real News Network.

End

DISCLAIMER: Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.



Comments

Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at contact@therealnews.com

latest stories

Paul Jay On Our Need For Monthly Donors
Trump's Labor Pick is Millionaire CEO Who Blames Workers for Their Poverty
Baltimore City Council members Defend Resolution Condemning Trump's Bigotry
Climate Scientists Speak Out Against Trump's Plans to Cut NASA Funding
Green Party of Canada Adopts Endorsement of Sanctions Against Israel
Political Prisoner Leonard Peltier Facing Potentially Fatal Medical Emergency
New Anti-BDS Bill in Senate Would Criminalize Criticism of Israel
Why Thousands Are Staying in Standing Rock Despite Army Corps's Decision to Halt the #DAPL
The Real News of the Day - Friday, December 9
Trump Nominee for Homeland Security John Kelly Favors Draconian Immigration Policy
New Baltimore Mayor Plans Regional Approach to Problems Like Poverty and Drug Addiction
Vijay Prashad: The Battle for Aleppo is Over
Should the Electoral College Be Abolished?
Trump Picks Leading Climate Denier to Head EPA During Time of Climate Crisis
Following Oakland Fire, Baltimore Evicts Residents of DIY Arts Space
The Real News of the Day - Thursday, December 8
The People's Tribunal on the Iraq War, Day One: Philip Giraldi
Trump Taiwan Phone Call Not an Impulsive Act
There's No Issue More Burning Than Creating Our Global Climate Change Bureau
U.S. Planned to Go to War with Japan and Germany Before Pearl Harbor Attack
The Real News of the Day - Wednesday, December 7
Anti-Government Carson to Lead Dept. of Housing and Urban Development
UN Admits Fault in Haiti's Cholera Outbreak as Country Faces Prospect of Famine
The Real News of the Day - Tuesday, December 6
The People's Tribunal on the Iraq War, Day One: John Kiriakou
The People's Tribunal on the Iraq War, Day One: John Cavanaugh
Austrian Presidential Election Shows How United Front Politics Can Defeat the Far Right
Standing Rock Cautiously Optimistic Following Denial of Easement For Dakota Access Pipeline
Italian Referendum Defeat is No Victory for the Right Wing
The Global Networks of the Resurging Far Right

TheRealNewsNetwork.com, RealNewsNetwork.com, The Real News Network, Real News Network, The Real News, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of Independent World Television inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and The Real News Network.

All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network. Click here for more

Problems with this site? Please let us know

Linux VPS Hosting by Stack Star Hosting