March 19, 2008

Senate hearing: GDP fails to measure progress

Martin Collier: We are what we measure and GDP does not measure what we value
Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here


Share to Facebook Share to Twitter

Supporting TRNN is a little like having my own television station. I can watch whatever I find interesting and at any time. I also enjoy the privilege of publishing my opinions on Disqus. - Gregory
Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


Martin Collier is founding Executive Director and a Managing Board Member of the Glaser Progress Foundation, created by Rob Glaser, CEO and Chairman of RealNetworks. At the Foundation, Collier oversees initiatives to: create new and better measures of national progress; support independent and progressive media; and strengthen the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria. He is the Treasurer for Grantmakers in Film and Electronic Media, a Board Member of ProgressNow and FUSE and an Advisory Board Member of Free Press. He is a past Board Member of the National Alliance of Media Arts and Culture. Before joining the Foundation, Collier was an analyst for the Washington State Senate and an attorney focused on environmental and consumer interest class action litigation.


Senate hearing:  GDP fails to measure progressZAA NKWETA, PRESENTER: Forty years ago, Senator Robert Kennedy gave a speech in which he questioned using the GNP as an indicator of economic prosperity in America.


ROBERT KENNEDY: Our gross domestic product now is over $800 billion a year. But that gross national product, if we judge the United States of America by that, counts air pollution and cigarette advertising and ambulances to clear our highways of carnage.


Please note that TRNN transcripts are typed from a recording of the program; The Real News Network cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


Echoing Kennedy's words, last week Senator Byron Dorgan of North Dakota held hearings on the usefulness of using gross domestic product as a measure of economic progress in the United States.


BYRON DORGAN, US SENATOR (D-ND): It's clear from the current economic circumstances in our country that we've not been accurately reflecting either the wealth or the stability of our economy. People work longer hours and have less time, and that would all be viewed in most cases as a positive in our GDP numbers. What can we do to better measure progress in our country?


After the hearing, Real News reporter Matthew Palevsky interviewed Martin Collier, director of the Glaser Foundation, a Seattle think tank interested in the reevaluation of the use of gross domestic product as a useful indicator of economic progress.

MATTHEW PALEVSKY, JOURNALIST: What are we missing when we look at GDP as an indicator of growth and economic success?

MARTIN COLLIER, DIRECTOR, GLASER FOUNDATION: GDP measures money changing hands. So when money doesn't change hands, it's missed. It counts negatives as positives. And it also leaves out a wide range of things that are very, very valuable to us. If there's an oil spill on Puget Sound, where I live in Seattle, GDP goes up, because [inaudible] are higher, there's cleanup crews, all sorts of things. If someone gets cancer, GDP goes up. We can measure the depletion of our natural resources. We don't do that. We could measure the impacts of pollution on health and property damage. And that's just two examples. What I would propose is that at least as often as GDP we present other statistics. What are real wages doing for ordinary people, for instance? What's the national debt look like? It's now up to $9 trillion. We've got 47 million people in this country without health insurance. We've got over 37 million people in poverty. Those things should be reported along with increases in GDP to give us a more complete picture. The most simple way to put it is you are what you measure, you get what you measure, and you fix what you measure. It's time to measure what matters most, it's time to measure what we value most, instead of simply valuing what we measure.


Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at

latest stories

Were Haitian Police Behind Assassination Attempt on Aristide?
New Provisions Eliminate Healthcare From GOP 'Wealthcare' Bill
Why Further Revelations on Trump's Russian Connections Might Fail to Bring Him Down
18 Million U.S. Citizens Exposed to Lead-Contaminated Water Systems
Russia vs. USA: Who is the Threat, Who is the Aggressor? (2/2)
Should Sanders Continue the Fight Outside the Democratic Party?
Fed Inflation Target Keeping Wages Low, People Out of Jobs
Is Trump Dangerous for Russia?
Was the Georgian Conflict Started to Elect John McCain President in 2008? Pt.1
Will the NDP Adopt Pro-BDS Platform?
Massive Cuts to EPA Threaten Communities Already Suffering From Pollution, Climate Change
Whistle Blower Teacher Says Charter Schools Draining Students, Resources from Public Education
Trump's Budget Targets Climate Change Spending Across All Federal Agencies
US Has Interfered in More Elections Than Any Other Nation
Maryland Democrats Push Back Against Gov. Hogan's Support for ACA Repeal
Russia vs. USA: Who is the Threat, Who is the Aggressor? (1/2)
Democrats Fail to Dig into Trump's Shady Financial Ties During Hearing
Why is the Capitalist West Fighting with Capitalist Russia?
Baltimore City Council Passes Historic $15 Minimum Wage
UN Report Finds Apartheid Exists Within Israel
Neil Gorsuch's Woeful Record on Civil Rights
Federal Judge Orders Civil Rights Lawsuit Against Pocomoke, State of MD to Move Forward
Hundreds Rally to Demand A Fix to Baltimore's School Budget Deficit
Trump Adds Another Goldman Sachs Alum to His Administration
Empire Files: Abby Martin Exposes Steve Bannon
Wealthiest U.S. Households Save Big Under GOP Health Care Bill
'They are Taking Everyone': Families March Against Deportations in Phoenix
Baltimore Poised to Pass $15 Min. Wage as Business Lobby Launches Nationwide Rollback Campaign
Bankruptcy Protection, Debt Jubilee, Students Debt and the Credit System
BDS Activist Speaks About His Arrest by Israeli Police,, The Real News Network, Real News Network, The Real News, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of Independent World Television inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and The Real News Network.

All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network. Click here for more

Problems with this site? Please let us know

Managed Wordpress Hosting