• Latest News
  • Pitch a Story
  • Work with a Journalist
  • Join the Blog Squad
  • Afghanistan
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Baltimore
  • Canada
  • Egypt
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • Middle East
  • Russia
  • Economy
  • Environment
  • Health Care
  • Military
  • Occupy
  • Organize This
  • Reality Asserts Itself
  • US Politics
  • Shutting Down Critique of Israel on Campus

    Michael Ratner: Regulations against hate speech used to close down criticism of Israeli occupation -   April 10, 13
    Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here


      Share to Twitter
    Share to Facebook

    Understanding info is a powerful thing. Thank you to all of your reporters for making a significant difference. - Nancy SmithEaken
    Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


    Michael Ratner is President Emeritus of the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) in New York and Chair of the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights in Berlin. He is currently a legal adviser to Wikileaks and Julian Assange. He and CCR brought the first case challenging the Guantanamo detentions and continue in their efforts to close Guantanamo. He taught at Yale Law School, and Columbia Law School, and was President of the National Lawyers Guild. His current books include "Hell No: Your Right to Dissent in the Twenty-First Century America," and “ Who Killed Che? How the CIA Got Away With Murder.” NOTE: Mr. Ratner speaks on his own behalf and not for any organization with which he is affiliated.


    Shutting Down Critique of Israel on CampusPAUL JAY, SENIOR EDITOR, TRNN: Welcome to The Real News Network. I'm Paul Jay in Baltimore. And welcome to this week's edition of the Ratner Report with Michael Ratner, who now joins us from New York City.

    Michael's the president emeritus of the Center for Constitutional Rights. He's chair of the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights in Berlin. He's a board member of The Real News. And he joins us.

    Thanks very much, Michael.

    RATNER: Paul, it's good to be with you again.

    JAY: So what are you--I know you're working on a ton of things every week, but what are you going to talk about this week?

    RATNER: You know, every week, there's so much going on, I could spend hours on your show. But I'm going to step back for a second, although it's really stepping forward as well. I want to talk about Palestine and Israel, but particularly the issue of free speech and dissent in the United States.

    And my view for a number of years has been, with regard to issues of Palestine, with regard to criticism of Israel in particular, there's what I call the Palestine exception to free speech or the Palestine exception to the First Amendment, which is our free speech protection in the United States. And when I say exception, what I mean is you can almost speak about anything in the United States, but the one thing that you get accused of and they try and stop you from speaking about is critiques of Israel with regard to the Palestinian people. And they call people who are oftentimes critical of Israel, they say they're engaging in anti-Jewish or antisemitic speech.

    In my experience and what I've looked at over the last number of years, particularly at universities where a lot of this dissent happens and where actually over the last month we've had anti-apartheid week with regard to Israel, where there's actually a lot of suppression of free speech and there's a lot of effort to stop critiques of Israel, and it comes off over things that are clearly not antisemitic--you oppose the occupation--the people who support Israel down the line say, well, that's antisemitic. You call Israel an apartheid state--antisemitic. Of course, it's not. You support BDS, boycott, divestment, and sanction--antisemitic. And I could go on. So the critiques people are making, particularly university students and others, around Israel's behavior is often, often deemed antisemitic.

    And the question I've asked myself over time is: how do we change a policy in the United States if the people who want to push for change in the United States can't engage in free speech on that policy? If we talk about John Stuart Mill and the idea that there's a marketplace of ideas, assuming there was any kind of equal media out there, which there's not, that you're trying to remedy, you at least have to get the ideas out there. And they're not getting out there, because critiques of Israel are suppressed.

    And CCR, my office, Center for Constitutional Rights, noticed this over the years and has been trying to represent people whose speech gets suppressed, as well as teach them their rights. We've set up a website called We give information, representation, etc., on that website.

    But let me give people a sense of what's going out there. They attack free speech--they being people who want to suppress this speech, whether they're, you know, heavy Zionists that don't want to hear the other side, don't want to debate the other side. Rather than debate it, they call it antisemitic. And they do it politically, they do it legally, and they do it by creating a climate of fear on the campuses for people who want to speak out on Israel.

    We just had one a few weeks ago here in New York when there were two speakers at Brooklyn College who were going to speak on boycott, divestment, and sanction. One of them really favored boycott, divestment, and sanction; the other one, while very critical of Israel, didn't favor it as strongly.

    And there was a huge what I call political attack on Brooklyn College for doing it. And what actually happened is a number of members of our city council, eight or ten at one time, wrote a letter to Brooklyn College, which is a public college, saying, we will consider withdrawing your funding if you continue to sponsor this biased, one-sided presentation. And, of course, yes. Did it have a pro-Zionist on there? No, it didn't.

    But this happens at universities all the time, as we all know. They're not required at a university to put both sides on every issue. And of course the person who did the most complaining here was Alan Dershowitz from Harvard. He speaks all the time as a Zionist without anybody opposing him. When I went to college, I heard Malcolm X speak. They didn't put someone on the other side with Malcolm X. A university doesn't have to balance every single panel. And that was in my view just a fig leaf or an excuse for attacking the panel.

    So here you have city councilmen saying, we're going to withdraw funding. To his credit, our mayor, Mayor Bloomberg, said, I support free speech at Brooklyn College. This is not, as he said, the university of North Korea. That's not what this is. This isn't a country like North Korea where you suppress speech. You let it happen. And he finally--I wouldn't say put an end to it, because it's still going on, in the sense that people are still now angry at the organizers, claiming that people were kicked out of the lecture, etc., but Bloomberg at least said the right thing on that issue.

    So it just--there's a political way in which universities get attacked, their funding gets threatened. That happened recently at Brooklyn College.

    There's a second, legal way, and that's something called Title 6, which most people are probably not familiar with. It's being used heavily at the University of California. It's being used by people who object to critiques of Israel. And Title 6 is part of our national statutes that prohibits discrimination based on race, color, or national origin. It does not say anything about prohibiting discrimination based on religion.

    But of course as this thing has heated up and the critiques of Israel have gotten stronger, and as obviously there's been more support for critiquing Israel in the world and particularly the United States, the so-called Zionist lobby is breaking apart, to a certain extent. There's more diversity in it. As that's increased, the Department of Education, which is where Title 6 complaints go to, expanded the definitions to basically say that antisemitism could be considered an attack, I presume, on national origin in some way or on maybe race. But they call it ethnicity. And they expanded it so complaints under Title 6 could be filed.

    And why they're important is that every educational institution in this country that gets any federal money is subject to Title 6. So a complaint against a university, like University of California or its constituent colleges, is taken seriously. It goes to the Department of Education, and federal funding can be cut off if it's found to be violating Title 6. And there's been half a dozen of these complaints filed.

    And when you look at them, the complaints are essentially complaints that are critical, critical of Zionism. And, in fact, in one of these cases--in two of these cases, the Center for Constitutional Rights has written letters to the university, and the ACLU did it as well. And the ACLU looked at these complaints under Title 6, saying, this is discrimination, and they said what is going on on these campuses are expressive speech and conduct that expresses opposition to the policies and actions of the state of Israel or the ideals of Zionism and are equivalent. And to say they are equivalent to anti-Zionism [sic] and hate speech is just ridiculous, and it should not come under Title 6. But those are going on.

    And even if they're in the end found wanting, even if the Department of Education says, this is just free speech, this is not antisemitism, this does not come under Title 6, what happens is investigations ensue, and people who are speaking out in criticism of Israel are very intimidated, and universities begin to get frightened, and they begin to suppress, really, free speech because they're afraid, afraid of these DOE complaints.

    And to give you some sense of how bad it's been going, particularly in California, but, as I just said, in New York as well, the assembly, state assembly in California passed a bill a few months ago basically trying to define antisemitism in a very broad way and saying that this kind of conduct constitutes antisemitism and should not be allowed. I'm just going to read you a couple of sentences. It's considered to be that falsely described Israel Zionists include--and Jews, including that Israel is a racist, apartheid, or Nazi state.

    Okay. Israel is a racist or apartheid state. I think--or a Nazi state. You can say it. It's not antisemitic. Or you can say Israel is guilty of heinous crimes against humanity, such as ethnic cleansing and genocide. Now, it seems to me that is not antisemitic. In fact, I read a book called The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine that talks about the destruction of some almost 700 villages in Palestine. Or to say that Jews in America wield excessive power over American foreign policy. Now, that's a much debated issue, but there's a lot of evidence about that. There's professors at Harvard who've written major books on it. It's considered a really important issue. And yet this resolution in California labels that kind of discussion as antisemitic. So there is not just the political; there's the legal.

    And then there's the third, which is there's a climate of hostility that's created for people who want to speak out on Israel at these campuses. They're criticized by their professor. They're given--they're yelled at and given names. Their speech is suppressed.

    What's really happened here, if you look at the political, the legal, and the climate that's created is that people who don't want to hear any criticism of Israel or its practices have actually done the exact reverse of what's really going on. What's really going on here is people who speak out on Israel, people who oppose the occupation, people who support BDS, boycott, divestment, and sanction, people who talk about the Zionist lobby in the United States as being powerful, those people's speech are being suppressed.

    The people who are speaking in favor, obviously, of Israel without any criticism, that's the speech that's allowed, that's the speech that's printed. And so they've basically turned this upside down. And it's--the reason that we at the Center founded this project, the Palestine legal support project: because we think that free speech, particularly around contentious issues like Israel and Palestine, is an absolute necessity in this country.

    JAY: Right. Well, the, you know, Zionist lobby has been able to create this idea that somehow criticizing Israel, the Jewish state, is equivalent to wanting genocide against Jews. They don't quite say it, but they treat these debates as if it's a debate whether to have genocide or not, which of course it's not. But that's the level it's treated at, because I suppose if you were going to have that kind of debate, that would be hate speech, and one could imagine closing that kind of a debate down, I suppose, should we have genocide or not. But nobody's saying those things.

    But let me just go come at this from another direction. While I would say the vast majority of criticism of Israel is not antisemitism, some is. I know from our stories--we do stories about Israel which have been very, very critical of Israeli policy. We get comments, especially on our YouTube site, some of which are just virulently racist comments, just anti-Jewish, racist comment. In fact, some of the stories that have nothing to do with Israel, many of our economic stories are permeated with many, many of these comments that are just filled with hatred of Jews and not really critique of Israel as much. So I think it's important to recognize that some of this critique of Israel actually is driven by racism.

    RATNER: Obviously, if you see that kind of stuff, that's one thing. But what I've come at and where we've seen over the years is what we see as really solid criticisms of Israel or its occupation or BDS or its human rights record, that's not antisemitic; that's critique. And what people have done is because there may be a few people out there with virulent antisemitism--just are there people with virulent anti-Muslim, in particular, is the other area where you see that--that does not mean you suppress speech altogether.

    And so my problem is is what's happened is the Zionists have really equated criticism of Israel with antisemitism. And that's just not right. It's not fair. And it's really suppressing an important, really important conversation that has to happen in this country.

    Of course there's antisemitism. As I said, there's antisemites, there's anti-Muslims, and anti-Christians. There's people who hate atheists. And they're out there, and they're virulent. And of course there's a special history, of course, with Jews and antisemitism because of the Holocaust. And so people are obviously very, very sensitive to that, as they should be.

    But to say that you can't do critiques of Israel because of what happened to Jews during the Holocaust seems to me completely unreasonable and cuts off, really, as I said, a crucial debate that's going to be necessary to actually get U.S. policy on track with what's required by law and human rights.

    JAY: Alright. Thanks for joining us, Michael.

    RATNER: Good to be with you again, Paul.

    JAY: And thank you for joining us on The Real News Network.


    DISCLAIMER: Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


    Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at


    Latest Stories

    The Modern History of Venezuela and Popular Democracy - Edgardo Lander on RAI (9/9)
    An Asia "Pivot" Should Mean Cooperating with China to Solve the Global Environmental Crisis
    Assessing the U.S. Environmental Movement
    Intimidation and Political Interference Goes Unpunished in UAW Case
    Exclusive Investigation Uncovers How BP Uses Bribes To Do Business
    The Modern History of Venezuela, The Protests and Democracy - Edgardo Lander on RAI (8/9)
    Greek Politics 4 Years After The Financial Crisis
    CBO Report Confirms U.S. Deficit Back to Normal Level
    Israel Uses Refugees as "Currency" in Arms Trade with Africa
    Who Will Pay for Climate Change Disaster?
    Canada Shifts to Right Under Harper, Mimicking the United States
    The Savings and Loan Crisis Demonstrates the Importance of Glass-Steagall
    South African Platinum Miner's Struggle Challenges ANC Leadership
    TRNN Original Report: Manning Determined to Fight Back After Army Upholds 35- Year Sentence
    Hundredth Anniversary of the Ludlow Massacre
    The Bundy Ranch Standoff Demonstrates Values Shared by Corporations and the Far Right
    The Resegregation of American Schools
    The Modern History of Venezuela, Why Still So Much Crime? - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (7/9)
    What Role Has Russia Played in Eastern Ukraine?
    Can Johns Hopkins Afford to Pay A Living Wage? (2/2)
    University Sit-In Targets World's Largest Private Coal Company
    The Modern History of Venezuela and the Need for a Post-Oil Economy - Edgardo Lander on RAI (6/9)
    Can Johns Hopkins Afford to Pay A Living Wage? (1/2)
    One Percent of Environmentalists Killings Lead to Convictions
    Investigation Finds Former Ukraine President Not Responsible For Sniper Attack on Protestors
    The Modern History of Venezuela from 1973 to the Caracazo Massacre - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (3/9)
    Ukraine Transitional Gov't Moves Militarily To Reclaim Seized Buildings
    IPCC Report Flawed By Narrow Focus on Carbon Emissions
    The Modern History of Venezuela: The Bolivarian Revolution - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (5/9)
    Obama Signs Directives to Reduce the Gender Wage Gap
    Eastern Ukraine Lacks Political Representation in Kiev
    Demystifying the Role of Mitigation in the Most Recent IPCC Report
    Hypersurveillance State Won't Prevent Another Boston Marathon Bombing
    The Modern History of Venezuela from 1973 to the Caracazo Massacre - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (3/9)
    Univ. of Maine Faculty Reinstated After Students Protest Against Cuts
    The Modern History of Venezuela from 1908 to 1973 - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (2/9)
    IMF Will Address Global Inequality, Says Managing Director Christine Lagarde
    Raising Big Banks' Leverage Ratio Good, But Not Nearly Enough
    TRNN Replay: Austerity Road to 19th Century
    Has Palestinian Maneuvering Revived Peace Talks?
    Late Jackson Mayor Lumumba's Son Wins Primary to Replace His Father, Runoff Election Ahead
    Quebecers Reject PQ and Elect a Liberal Government Representing Big Business
    TRNN Debate: Decriminalization vs. Legalization
    The Beginning of the Chavez Era - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (4/9)
    "Off With His Head": Court Upholds Obama's Power to Kill
    Workers at Nation's Top Hospital Strike For Fair Wages
    From Exile to Radicalization in Venezuela - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (1/9)
    Rwanda 20 Years Later: Genocide, Western Plunder of Congo, and President Kagame
    Ukrainian Protesters in the East Demand More Autonomy From Kiev Government
    Hunger Strikers Demand President Obama Halt His Record 2 Million Deportations
    Indian Parliamentary Elections - A Primer With Vijay Prashad
    West Looks to Carve Up Ukraine & Privatize Industries Held by Kleptocrats
    Where Are Israeli-Palestinian Peace Negotiations Headed?
    The Multiple Kingdoms of Saudi Arabia (5/5)
    Do the Afghan Presidential Elections Signify Progress?
    Republican Presidential Hopefuls Pay Homage to Billionaire Casino Tycoon Sheldon Adelson
    Will Extremist Lieberman Become Israel's Next Prime Minister?
    Why do the Saudis Want the US to Attack Iran? (4/5)
    Immigrant Advocates and Families Tell President Obama 'Not One More'
    Elections, Pipelines, and Protests - The Canada Panel
    Chris Hedges on "Israel's War on American Universities"
    Baltimore Residents Decry Lack of Affordable Housing
    Yellen Talks the Talk But Will She Walk the Walk?
    Hopkins Hospital Workers Speak Out against "Poverty Wages"
    Will Venezuela's New Floating Exchange Rate Curb Inflation?
    The European Central Bank's War on Wages is Pushing Europe's Economy to the Brink
    Supreme Court Decision Opens Floodgates for More Campaign Cash
    Charles Keating, the Financier Behind the Savings and Loan Scandal, Dies at 90
    Saudi Arabia and the al-Qaeda Monster (3/5)
    Maryland Residents Voice Opposition to Natural Gas Fracking Export Facility
    Supreme Court Ruling Gives Wealthy Individuals More Influence Over Elections
    What are the Saudis Afraid Of? - Madawi Al-Rasheed (2/5)
    Baltimore's MICA Adjunct Professors Set to Vote on Unionization
    Boycott of Israel Moving to Next Level?
    Hypocrisy Dressed Up as "Realism" Justifies American Alliance with Saudi Dictatorship
    Immigration Reform in the Shadows of Cesar Chavez's Legacy
    Leaked Senate Report Shows Use of Torture As "Ineffective"
    UN Report Says Climate Change Will Threaten Food Production Worldwide
    The Hypocrisy of US Calling for Enforcement of International Law
    How the Ecuadorian Economy Grew in a Global Recession
    'Shadows of Liberty' Trailer
    Kristina Borjesson on Why CBS Shut Down Her investigation into Flight 800 (2/8)
    Glen Ford on Racism in the American Media (3/8)
    Paul Jay on What Drives Corporate Media and What Drive The Real News (4/8)
    Creating a New Media Paradigm After Citizens United (5/8)
    Should The Left Engage with the Mainstream Media? (6/8)
    What Is the Financial Backing For The Real News? (7/8)
    Standing up to Character Assassination (8/8)
    Oligarchs, Fascists and the People's Protest in Ukraine
    TRNN Debate: Is Obamacare In the Interest of Workers?
    Too-Big-To-Fail Advantage Remains Intact For Big Banks
    Obama and the Saudi Agenda
    TRNN Replay: Investigating the Saudi Government's 9/11 Connection and the Path to Disilliusionment - Sen. Graham on Reality Asserts Itself pt 1
    The Iraq War's Real Legacy
    Petitions with 100,000+ Signatures Call for Snowden's Passport to be Reinstated
    We Need to Harness People Power - Andy Shallal on Reality Asserts Itself (4/4)
    BC Pipeline Fight and Quebec Elections - The Canada Panel
    Jonathan Schell - 1943-2014: Board Member of TRNN on Why We Need The Real News
    Teachers on Strike from the UK to Argentina
    Connecticut Poised to Become First State with $10.10 Minimum Wage
    Oil Spill Threatens Wildlife and Local Economy
    DC School Test Scores Up, But Poor Black Kids Are Doing Worse - Andy Shallal on RAI (3/4)
    Obama's Proposal To End NSA Bulk Data Collection Won't Protect Privacy
    How Google, Apple & The Biggest Tech Companies Colluded to Fix Workers' Wages
    An American Should be One that Questions Their Government - Andy Shallal on RAI (2/4)
    What's Driving Putin & Obama's Posturing on Ukraine?
    Hundreds of Students & Faculty Occupy College Campus to Fight Cuts to Public Higher Ed
    Due Process 'Impossible' In Harsh Death Sentencing Of Over 500 Muslim Brotherhood Members
    Has Anglo-American Capitalism Run Out of Steam?
    Being the "Other" in America - Andy Shallal on Reality Asserts Itself (1/4)
    TRNN Debate: Should Baltimore 'Ban The Box'?
    How Fallujah Became the Iraqi Government's New Battleground
    Why I Decided to Blow the Whistle on the NSA
    NASA Climate Predictions Show Serious Threat To Humanity
    Professor Who Teaches Israel-Palestine Conflict Accuses College of Violating His Academic Freedom
    CIA and NSA Wrongdoing Requires Independent Investigation, Says Former Church Committee Staff
    Are Tuition Breaks Enough To Combat High Student Debt And Low Graduation Rates?
    Industries Across the U.S. Are Stealing Wages From Their Lowest Paid Workers
    Who In Ukraine Will Benefit From An IMF Bailout?
    NSA Recording All International Calls From U.S.
    Israel "Making Lives Miserable" for Africans, Hoping They 'Self-Deport' (2/2)
    BP Gets Green Light to Drill in Gulf, But Has Safety Improved?
    Residents Still Not Drinking Tap Water Two Months After West Virginia Spill (1/2)
    Libya's Descent Into Turmoil Three Years After NATO Intervention
    From Pipelines to Peladeau - Canadian Report
    Israel "Making Lives Miserable" for Africans, Hoping They 'Self-Deport' (1/2)
    Congressional Progressive Caucus Budget Strikes Back Against Austerity
    Libya Three Years Later - Chaos and Partition
    Why Was Gaddafi Overthrown?
    Should Ukraine and West Accept De Facto Crimea Joining Russia? (2/2)
    Tony Benn Saw Socialism as the Culmination of Democratization
    Why Didn't Bush/Cheney Attack Iran and Can Obama Make and Sell a Deal? - Gareth Porter on Reality Asserts Itself (3/3)
    After Late Mayor Lumumba is Laid to Rest, What's Next for Jackson, Mississippi? (2/2)
    Crimea Referendum: Self Determination or Big Power Manipulation? (1/2)
    Sen. Graham: President Must Side with Openness About CIA and 9/11
    Manufacturing a Narrative for War - Gareth Porter on Reality Asserts Itself (2/3)
    Protesters Hit the Streets of Brooklyn to Demand $15 Minimum Wage
    Hammer: 'Moral Bankruptcy' Behind Massive GM Recall
    White House Withholds Thousands of Documents from Senate CIA Probe
    I Grew Up Believing in Time Magazine's Version of America - Gareth Porter on RAI (1/3)
    Western European Banks Vulnerable to Ukrainian Sovereign Debt Crisis
    TRNN Debate: What's Driving Inflation in Venezuela? (2/2)
    CIA vs. Senate: Who Is Obama Protecting?
    Will Tipped Workers Get Excluded Again From Minimum Wage Hike?
    TRNN Debate: What's Driving Inflation in Venezuela? (1/2)
    After Late Mayor Lumumba is Laid to Rest, What's Next for Jackson, Mississippi?(1/2)
    TRNN Replay: A Look at Who's Poised to Become No.2 at the Fed
    How Right-Wing Nationalism Rose to Influence in Ukraine (2/2)
    Netanyahu Attacks Boycott As Campaign Enters New Phase
    Moving Towards a Police State - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (7/7)
    Fighting Reagan's Secret, Illegal Wars - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (6/7)
    Puerto Rican Independence Movement and Cuba Further Radicalized Me - Michael Ratner on RAI (5/7)
    The Butcher of Attica - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (4/7)
    MLK and a Radicalizing Moment in American History - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (3/7), Real News Network, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of IWT.TV inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and Real News Network.

    All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network.  Click here for more

    Problems with this site? Please let us know

    Linux VPS Hosting by Star Dot Hosting