UN: Israel Executed Flotilla Activists
NO ADVERTISING, GOVERNMENT OR CORPORATE FUNDING
DONATE TODAY
 $124,188


  September 30, 2010

UN: Israel Executed Flotilla Activists


Gareth Porter: UN Fact-Finding Mission Says Israelis "Executed" US Citizen Furkan Dogan
Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here
   


audio

Share to Facebook Share to Twitter



I've made my way to my current internet haven: The Real News Network (TRNN). - Caroline Lewis
Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


biography

Gareth Porter is a historian and investigative journalist on US foreign and military policy analyst. He writes regularly for Inter Press Service on US policy towards Iraq and Iran. Author of four books, the latest of which is Perils of Dominance: Imbalance of Power and the Road to War in Vietnam.


transcript

UN: Israel Executed Flotilla ActivistsPAUL JAY, SENIOR EDITOR, TRNN: Welcome to The Real News Network. I'm Paul Jay in Washington. On September 22, a fact-finding mission created by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights on the Israeli attack on the Gaza flotilla was released and showed—according to some, conclusively—who was responsible for the deaths that took place. The fact-finding mission was chaired by Judge Karl T. Hudson-Phillips, QC, a retired judge of the International Criminal Court, former attorney general of Trinidad and Tobago, and included other jurists from around the world. And joining us now is Gareth Porter, investigative journalist and often contributor to The Real News Network. Thanks for joining us.

GARETH PORTER, INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALIST: Thank you, Paul.

JAY: So what did the report conclude?

PORTER: The report concluded that a US citizen, Furkan Dogan, a 19-year-old US citizen, and five Turkish citizens were deliberately murdered by Israeli commandos on board the Mavi Marmara, the ship that was taken over violently by the Israeli commandos. It really provided very specific evidence that both Furkan Dogan and the five Turkish citizens were in fact killed when they were incapacitated, unable to resist, were clearly not a threat to the Israeli commandos. So it's really the clearest and most convincing evidence that has been published, and obviously from an official source, that this was an execution-style murder.

JAY: Okay. Just to give context for—not perhaps everyone remembers this—there's an aid flotilla going, trying to get to Gaza to break the Israeli blockade of Gaza. One of the boats—I can't remember, the six or seven boats, one of the boats is selected, and the commandos actually drop from helicopters down onto the boat, and shooting takes place. And up until now, the Israelis have been saying there were shots fired at them, there were knives and other things used, and the people shot were actually the aggressors, and the commandos were defending themselves.

PORTER: Correct.

JAY: So how does this fact-finding mission, how have they determined that's not true?

PORTER: Well, first of all, they interviewed 121 eyewitnesses to what happened. They tried to interview Israeli officials and IDF personnel, of course, but the Israeli government refused to cooperate, refused to have anything to do with the inquiry, and so they were unable to do that. But most importantly, they had access to the autopsy reports which were carried out by Turkish medical personnel on the dead, as well as, equally important, the medical forensic reports, which were actually tissue studies and detailed forensic reports which were vital in judging exactly what happened. And on the basis of that, they were able to assess the evidence that they were given. They also had their own experts on both the forensics, the medical forensics, and on firearms, so that they would have their own expertise in order to evaluate the evidence [inaudible]

JAY: I'll read a quote from a piece, your article, about this, which quotes the report. The report says Dogan had apparently been, quote, "'lying on the deck in a conscious or semi-conscious state for some time' before being shot in his face. The forensic evidence that establishes that fact is 'tattooing around the wound in his face,' indicating that the shot was 'delivered at point blank range.' The report describes the forensic evidence as showing that 'the trajectory of the wound, from bottom to top, together with a vital abrasion to the left shoulder that could be consistent with the bullet exit point, is compatible with the shot being received while he was lying on the ground on his back.'"

PORTER: Yes. I think this is the key point in the entire report. That is to say, they found evidence which was really quite incontrovertible that these people, and particularly Furkan Dogan, the 19-year-old American citizen, could not have been shot in a situation where they were threatening the Israeli officers.

JAY: Now, you point out in your article that the White House has known this, that the Turkish autopsy report has been available to them, and this is an American citizen, but the White House has not said anything. So, first of all, how do we know in fact that that they did have this autopsy report? And then, why haven't they said something?

PORTER: I started working on this back in July and was told by a source in the US government, in the Obama administration, that—and this was in early August—I was told that indeed the autopsy report which was held by the Turkish authorities had been turned over to the US Embassy in July, and that it was then passed on to the Justice Department, which was supposed to use this as the basis for a decision as to whether an independent US investigation by the Justice Department was appropriate. And, of course, we've heard absolutely nothing. Nothing has happened even after the publication of this report, which provides, again, additional information. By the way, I am convinced that the Justice Department also has the medical forensic reports, not just the autopsy reports. So they have the full set of documentation which was available to the UN fact-finding commission. But what I think is going on here is that the Obama administration had a very firm policy: we are not going to say anything about this matter; we're going to keep it quiet.

JAY: You suggested in your article that someone from the State Department was actually saying, we're not going to do anything that might upset the negotiation process.

PORTER: That's right. The day, two days ago, when I published this story, I called the State Department, tried to get a comment, and what I was told was by somebody who was not able to speak on the record: we believe that this report is biased, not objective in its tone and conclusions, and we think it should not be used to disrupt the talks which are directly going on between the Palestinians and the Israelis or the talks that are going on between Israel and Turkey.

JAY: Now, one of the things you point out in your article is that the fact-finding commission found that the Israeli armed forces had not communicated anything to the ships. What is that about? 'Cause that's a complete contradiction of what the Israeli armed forces have said.

PORTER: Absolutely. This is a very key point, because the rationale, of course, on the part of the Israeli government and IDF [Israeli Defense Forces] was that they were there to intercept possible weapons going to Hamas in Gaza. That was the rationale for the interception of the ships and taking them over. However, what the fact-finding mission found, as you suggested, is that the Israeli ships surrounding or approaching the Gaza flotilla never communicated by radio to any of the ships saying, we would like to board peaceably to inspect the cargo.

JAY: Now, in that report, do they explain how they know something like that? 'Cause presumably they only have one side of the story, 'cause Israel wouldn't cooperate with their fact-finding mission.

PORTER: Well, I assume that they had access to the ship's logs and to electronic recordings of the entire ship.

JAY: But in the report itself do they explain?

PORTER: It did not mention that, but that would be my assumption, that they were able to ascertain what sort of communications there were between the ship and any other ships during the voyage.

JAY: The other big issue here is the story broke on September 22. You wrote a piece for Truthout. Most of the media has not even mentioned this.

PORTER: Well, it's actually worse than that, Paul. Not a single US-based news media, corporate news source, has done a story pointing out that Furkan Dogan, the 19-year-old US citizen, was killed under circumstances which clearly indicate that this was an execution. It's been completely blacked out, in other words, in the United States. Of course, it's been picked up by the Turkish media. They've covered it very extensively. The BBC had a story which talked about the report. It did not mention specifically this evidence about the nature of the killing of Furkan Dogan and the five Turkish citizens. So, otherwise, other than the Turkish media, this has been blacked out across the globe.

JAY: So what's the next step? What does the UN human rights commissioner do now with this information?

PORTER: Well, I think this is one of those cases where it's up to alternative media to get the story out and to develop some pressure on institutions in this country to raise this issue, to say to the Obama administration, how can you in good conscience refuse to lift a finger to even carry out your own investigation of the killing of a US citizen on board this ship, when you know that there is very clear and convincing evidence that he was murdered deliberately?

JAY: Thanks very much for joining us.

PORTER: Thank you.

JAY: And thank you for joining us on The Real News Network.

End of Transcript

DISCLAIMER: Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.



Comments

Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at contact@therealnews.com

latest stories

Paul Jay On Our Need For Monthly Donors
Obama Calls for Investigation into Russian Hacking, Still No Evidence Made Public
Trump's Labor Pick is Millionaire CEO Who Blames Workers for Their Poverty
Baltimore City Council members Defend Resolution Condemning Trump's Bigotry
Climate Scientists Speak Out Against Trump's Plans to Cut NASA Funding
Green Party of Canada Adopts Endorsement of Sanctions Against Israel
Political Prisoner Leonard Peltier Facing Potentially Fatal Medical Emergency
New Anti-BDS Bill in Senate Would Criminalize Criticism of Israel
Why Thousands Are Staying in Standing Rock Despite Army Corps's Decision to Halt the #DAPL
The Real News of the Day - Friday, December 9
Trump Nominee for Homeland Security John Kelly Favors Draconian Immigration Policy
New Baltimore Mayor Plans Regional Approach to Problems Like Poverty and Drug Addiction
Vijay Prashad: The Battle for Aleppo is Over
Should the Electoral College Be Abolished?
Trump Picks Leading Climate Denier to Head EPA During Time of Climate Crisis
Following Oakland Fire, Baltimore Evicts Residents of DIY Arts Space
The Real News of the Day - Thursday, December 8
The People's Tribunal on the Iraq War, Day One: Philip Giraldi
Trump Taiwan Phone Call Not an Impulsive Act
There's No Issue More Burning Than Creating Our Global Climate Change Bureau
U.S. Planned to Go to War with Japan and Germany Before Pearl Harbor Attack
The Real News of the Day - Wednesday, December 7
Anti-Government Carson to Lead Dept. of Housing and Urban Development
UN Admits Fault in Haiti's Cholera Outbreak as Country Faces Prospect of Famine
The Real News of the Day - Tuesday, December 6
The People's Tribunal on the Iraq War, Day One: John Kiriakou
The People's Tribunal on the Iraq War, Day One: John Cavanaugh
Austrian Presidential Election Shows How United Front Politics Can Defeat the Far Right
Standing Rock Cautiously Optimistic Following Denial of Easement For Dakota Access Pipeline
Italian Referendum Defeat is No Victory for the Right Wing

TheRealNewsNetwork.com, RealNewsNetwork.com, The Real News Network, Real News Network, The Real News, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of Independent World Television inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and The Real News Network.

All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network. Click here for more

Problems with this site? Please let us know

Linux VPS Hosting by Stack Star Hosting