NO ADVERTISING, GOVERNMENT OR CORPORATE FUNDING

  • Latest News
  • Pitch a Story
  • Work with a Journalist
  • Join the Blog Squad
  • Afghanistan
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Baltimore
  • Canada
  • Egypt
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • Middle East
  • Russia
  • Economy
  • Environment
  • Health Care
  • Military
  • Occupy
  • Organize This
  • Reality Asserts Itself
  • US Politics
  • Howard Zinn on taxes and class war


    Howard Zinn: The US has always had class war over who gets taxed Pt.3 -   October 24, 2008
    Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here

    Audio

      Share to Twitter
    Share to Facebook




    Amongst "independent" media the only one which (so far) has served only insight and versatility. - Håkan
    Log in and tell us why you support TRNN

    Bio

    Howard Zinn was an American historian, political scientist, social critic, activist and playwright. He is best known as author of the best-seller 'A People's History of the United States'. Zinn has been active in the Civil Rights and the anti-war movements in the United States. Howard Zinn passed away on January 27, 2010. Zinn was raised in a working-class family in Brooklyn, and flew bombing missions for the United States in World War II, an experience he now points to in shaping his opposition to war. In 1956, he became a professor at Spelman College in Atlanta, a school for black women, where he soon became involved in the Civil rights movement, which he participated in as an adviser to the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee SNCC and chronicled, in his book SNCC The New Abolitionists. Zinn collaborated with historian Staughton Lynd and mentored a young student named Alice Walker. When he was fired in 1963 for insubordination related to his protest work, he moved to Boston University, where he became a leading critic of the Vietnam War.

    Precis

    In part three of our discussion with author and historian Howard Zinn, Prof. Zinn lays out his analysis of taxes as a class phenomenon. He points to the current discussion of politicians as either pro-tax or anti-tax instead of discussing who will be taxed as an example of the misunderstanding of taxation being promoted. Prof. Zinn submits that the United States has always had a class war, and as such it is ridiculous to accuse people of inciting class war through talk of taxation. He then outlines his proposal that higher taxes for the rich and cutting taxes for the poor will be necessary for addressing the roots of the economic crisis.

    Transcript

    Howard Zinn on taxes and class warWhy I support the REAL News

    (a short message from a member)

    BELLA LAM, REAL NEWS MEMBER: And I think The Real News, what I really like is at least it tries to engage us to really learn more about the issues that affect us.

    TEXT ON SCREEN: Howard Zinn is an American historian, political scientist, social critic, activist and playwright. He is best known as author of the best-seller 'A People's History of the United States.' Zinn has been active in the Civil Rights and the anti-war movements in the United States.

    Taxes and class war

    Paul Jay

    PAUL JAY, SENIOR EDITOR, TRNN: Welcome back to the next segment of our interview with Howard Zinn. And we're talking about taxes. So, Howard, where we left off in the last segment, we were talking about the great religious principle of no taxes, as seem to be part of the fundamental American psyche. How did it get to be like that? It's not like that in most other places in the world. How did "taxes" become such a dirty word in America?

    HOWARD ZINN, HISTORIAN AND AUTHOR: Well, I think "taxes" became a dirty word because the media and our educational institutions [inaudible] following the lead of our politicians, as too often they do, and all of them seem to be conspiring to prevent the American people from understanding that taxes are a class phenomenon. And when you keep class out of the tax discussion, what you end up with is candidates saying, "I will raise taxes" or "I will lower taxes," and you have the media saying, "Well, so-and-so suggests higher taxes, so-and-so suggests lower taxes," and not asking, "Taxes on whom?" You can't just talk about will we raise taxes or lower taxes.

    JAY: But the most honest moment of this was, I think, in the final presidential debate. Obama's been talking about the middle class, the middle class, the middle class, which presupposes there must be some other classes. If there's a middle class, there's got to be a lower class and an upper class at the very least. And McCain kind of said, "Well, you're talking about class war." Now, he's trying to, obviously, be provocative, but there's something in it: if you're going to defend the middle class, then you're going to have to tax somebody.

    ZINN: It's interesting. Whenever a candidate dares to say anything that suggests that there are classes, the opposition comes up, "Oh, you're inciting class war," which is really an absurd statement. We've always had class war in this country.

    JAY: You're just not supposed to talk about it.

    ZINN: That's right. Always had class war. We always had rich and poor; we've always had uprisings of the poor against the rich; we've always had the rich taking the helm of government and doing what they wanted for themselves. The tax structure has always been based on who do we tax. In the 1920s, Andrew Mellon, secretary of the treasury, started taxing people at the lower elements, leaving the upper classes untouched. What we need at this point is for some candidate—and Obama may be getting close to it when he talks about, well, he is going to relieve the bottom 90 percent of the population of taxes—need somebody to say, "I am going to raise taxes," but then go beyond that and say, "I'm going to raise taxes on the super-rich. They have made trillions of dollars in taxes." I mean, I saw a statistic which told me that the richest people in the country, the billionaires, as a result of the tax structure, have made $300 billion dollars in the last few years. Now, raise taxes on the super-rich, cut taxes on the people at the bottom, and you will have enough money by raising those taxes to pay for free health care for everybody in the country. And so far no candidate, well, including Obama, although he's getting close to it, has made this point, which is a point about the class nature of taxation.

    JAY: With the need for the American state to defend Treasury bonds in the global financial system and the role of the US dollar, it would seem reality is going to force something, 'cause you can only borrow and print money for so long. Eventually there has to be some taxation to back up the dollar, or someday people are going to give up on the dollar.

    ZINN: Yes, there has to be taxation, and the money is there to be taxed. I mean, we have an enormous amount of wealth accumulated at the very top of the economic ladder. And a large part of this accumulation has been done not just in the eight years of the Bush administration but even in the decades before that, because the tax structure since World War II has moved consistently in the direction of lowering the taxes on the richest part of the population.

    JAY: Now, there are some members of the elite who also say this. You can hear an argument like this from Soros; you can hear it from a Buffett. There seems to be sectors of the very wealthy who see the kind of almost self-destructive nature in this no-tax craziness. But are they just a couple of anomalies? Or is there really some history to a section of the elite that understands this?

    ZINN: Well, there's always been a small section of the elite that sees the longer picture, "the longer picture" meaning that they realize if they don't make concessions, if they're not willing to make some small sacrifice now, they may face rebellion, disaster later on. And I think that was some of the thinking behind the rich people who backed the Roosevelt administration; they thought that, "Yeah, these reforms are necessary, because this country's in turmoil, and this country could be getting close to revolution." So there have always been people in the upper classes, some people, a small minority. But it's helpful to have them.

    JAY: You see it also in—I know you're in touch with them—there are a lot of celebrities who have done very well, but are taking very openly progressive positions right now on the war, but also on economic issues. I mean, and the last time we saw something like this was the '30s. I mean, does this have a bit of a '30s vibe, to use a more modern term?

    ZINN: Oh, I think it does. And I think we have a situation like the '30s, in that we're desperately in need of not just working people to organize—we need that, we need working people to organize, but we need people in the other classes, and people in the professional classes, and people who are doing very well to create an alliance with the people at the bottom in order to bring about change.

    JAY: In the next segment of our interview, let's talk about the deepening economic crisis and how it might affect US foreign policy. Please join us for the next segment of our interview with Howard Zinn.

    DISCLAIMER:

    Please note that TRNN transcripts are typed from a recording of the program; The Real News Network cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


    Comments

    Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at contact@therealnews.com

    Comments


    Latest Stories


    19 Killed in Gaza as Israel Strikes Second UN Compound in a Week
    IRS Failing to Regulate Dark-Money Political Spending
    Could Britain Be Leaving the EU?
    Racing to a Dead End - Heiner Flassbeck on Reality Asserts Itself (2/5)
    Obama Joins EU in Sanctioning Russia as Ukraine's Civilian Death Toll Mounts
    Who's Profiting from Israel's Offensive in Gaza?
    Iran Nuclear Negotiations Remain Deadlocked, Receive 4-Month Extension
    The Politics of Going Green
    Who Bears Responsibility for Civilian Deaths in Gaza?
    Despite Growing International Condemnation, No End to Gaza Violence in Sight
    Reaganism and Thatcherism were Intellectually Dishonest - Heiner Flassbeck on Reality Asserts Itself (1/5)
    Besieged War-Torn Gaza Experiencing Saddest Eid Since 1967
    Do US Satellite Images Show Russia Firing Rockets into Ukraine?
    Uber: Cheap Ride Alternative or Death Knell for Cabbies?
    Gaza Baker Risks Life Amid War to Provide Bread
    New Senate Bill Fails To Address Root Causes of Central American Migration
    One-Man Show "Mercy Killers" Reveals Dark Side of Healthcare System
    Nigerians Must Defend Themselves, Oppose the State of Emergency and US Intervention (3/3)
    Why Canada Continues to Back Israel Despite Gaza Assault
    UN's Investigation of Israel Should Go Beyond War Crimes to Genocide
    12-Hour Truce in Gaza, Protests in the West Bank
    Al-Aqsa Brigades Open Fire on Israeli Forces at the Qalandia Checkpoint.
    From Palestine to Baltimore, Protesters Demand an End to Bloody Gaza Assault
    Israel Boycott Gains Traction As Gaza Assault Continues
    No Safe Place in Gaza: How Silence Encouraged a Genocide
    Detroit Water Shutoffs on Pause, but Is It Enough?
    Obamacare Subsides on the Line
    TRNN Gaza Reporter's Family Killed in Israeli Assault
    Is Israeli Public Opinion Turning after 700 Palestinian Deaths?
    Big Oil and the Nigerian Frankenstein (2/3)

    RealNewsNetwork.com, Real News Network, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of IWT.TV inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and Real News Network.

    All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network.  Click here for more

    Problems with this site? Please let us know

    Linux VPS Hosting by Star Dot Hosting