NO ADVERTISING, GOVERNMENT OR CORPORATE FUNDING
DONATE TODAY



  February 24, 2016

Is BDS Headed Towards Criminalization in Canada?


Grace Batchoun of Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East says Canada's Liberal government just passed a motion that could stifle or even suppress the voices behind the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement in Canada
Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here
   

Audio

Share to Facebook Share to Twitter



I support TRNN because it is the closest expression of the ideal of a free press I have seen. - Daniel
Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


transcript

Is BDS Headed Towards Criminalization in Canada?NADIA KANJI, TRNN: Welcome to the Real News Network. I'm Nadia Kanji in Baltimore.

Canada's Liberal government passed a Conservative-sponsored motion on Monday condemning the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions, or BDS movement, against Israel. The motion passed by a vote of 229-51, with about a dozen Liberals refusing to vote on the motion and one opposing it. The New Democratic Party voted against the measure, calling it an attack on free speech, as well as the right for individuals to hold diverse political views.

Joining us to discuss this is our guest, Grace Batchoun. Grace is the co-founder and VP Public Relations for Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East. Thanks so much for joining us, Grace.

GRACE BATCHOUN: My pleasure.

KANJI: In an interview with the Canadian Jewish News last year, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who opposes the BDS movement, said it was the new form of anti-semitism in the world, and an example of the three Ds: demonization of Israel, delegitimization of Israel, and double-standard applied toward Israel.

So is this motion a defeat of anti-semitism and an honest defense of Israel?

BATCHOUN: So if we look at what BDS is about--so let's talk about facts, okay. It's very easy to say it's this, it's this, it's that. But let's just talk. What are the demands of BDS? That's what I ask every single politician to go. When you discuss something, when you debate something, get the facts. Put the positions on the table.

So what are the demands of BDS, okay? Number one, they want the end of the occupation. This is exactly the same demands, the same position, as of our Canadian foreign policy. We want the end of the occupation, and the dismantling of the wall. So the end of the occupation, dismantling of the wall, and the end of the colonization. We are, everyone, everyone is against the illegal colonies. So that's number one.

Number two, the BDS movement is asking for equal rights for Palestinians, Arabs, inside Israel as the other Israelis and Jews inside Israel. So they're asking for equal rights. And the third thing is finding a fair and just solution for the resolution of the refugee question, and the respect of resolution 194. What's interesting, Nadia, is that the demands of BDS are 100 percent aligned with our foreign policy. Just go, I really encourage everyone just to go to the website of Canadian foreign policy, and look out word by word, as if, honestly, the BDS movement had copied the foreign affairs policy of our Canadian government. So that is what BDS is all about.

KANJI: It's interesting that you bring that up, Grace, because on the other side your organization, Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East, have, you know, lobbied [in peace] to support BDS. So I'd like to know, in your experience, in this motion, was there political pressure for Liberals and Conservatives to vote in favor of this motion, and can you go into that? To what degree does Canadian foreign policy interest shape this?

BATCHOUN: This is a very good question. We know the Conservatives had put out that motion. We know that Mr. Dion said he's not comfortable with this motion. But what I find it hard to accept, if you're not comfortable with something, why are you voting for it? You are the majority government. Don't forget, you as Liberal party, you've got the majority. Mr. Dion said the Conservatives are bullies. So if you know the Conservatives are bullies, why are you letting them to bully you? Why don't you stand up and say no?

And then I don't know if people know, but the second part of the motion, it talks about condemning any and all individuals and organizations who are supporting BDS. Since when? How about our Charter of Rights and Freedoms? How about our [inaud.].

KANJI: But going back to this foreign policy element, going back to this foreign policy element, what are Canada's interests with Israel? Like, what--are you saying that this, Canada's foreign policy with Israel is somehow part of the reason why this motion has come into place? What are those interests?

BATCHOUN: I really feel Canadians and members of parliament really need to start looking at our Canadian foreign policy. Our Canadian foreign policy, we have a very good foreign policy, but really need to apply it. That's the problem. We have an excellent Canadian foreign policy. Let's just apply it. This is a motion that was presented by the Conservatives. We know what are the positions of the Conservatives. It's all right and wrong, or wrong. There's no questioning about anything. They call all kinds of name on BDS without really knowing what BDS is.

So if you are someone who cares about justice, if you're someone who cares about children's rights, why wouldn't you want to support, as well, Palestinian human rights?

KANJI: And could this lead to the criminalization of BDS in Canada under hate speech laws?

BATCHOUN: I don't--I honestly don't think so. Like, how could you criminalize someone for his right to buy or not buy? I, I have the right to decide how to spend my money. If I don't want to buy products from Saudi Arabia, no one could oblige me to buy products. So it just makes--honestly, for me, it just makes no sense. Like, who are you? Like, why--what role--. The government has no role in telling Canadians what to buy or what not to buy, what to do or what not to do.

KANJI: So do you think this is an affront to free speech in Canada? I mean, Thomas Mulcair has called it a thoughtcrime--like, has said this motion makes it a thoughtcrime to express an opinion.

BATCHOUN: We really have to go back to our values. What do we believe in? Do people have the right for freedom of expression? And then sometimes I wonder, I got so many emails this morning, and someone said, look, with everything that happened with the Charlie Hebdo, all of us, all of us, we're Charlie, we're Charlie, we're Charlie, because we are for the freedom of expression. But as soon as someone tries to open up his mouth to promote human rights for the Palestinians, right away that person is muzzled. Why? Why? Do we really believe in freedom of expression, or are we just a bunch of hypocrites who are selective and apply freedom of expression as it suits them?

KANJI: Lastly, can you tell us about your campaign? CJPME has come out with a campaign, Make My Day, Condemn Me. What is this, exactly?

BATCHOUN: Well, this has been pretty much to challenge this government to say, like, really that motion, honestly if I could say that, just stupid. It makes no sense. Like, how could you dare to say we're going to condemn any organization, any individual here and abroad? Like, this is the government who's saying we're going to--these are members of parliament who signed on to say this is what we're going to do. So someone here on our team, he says, I'm ready, please, go ahead and condemn me. If you want to condemn me for promoting human rights, I'm really proud to be condemned, to be known everywhere that yes, I am promoting human rights.

And by the way, we are promoting Canadian foreign policy. So I think it's time for our members of parliament to start learning what is Canadian foreign policy, [inaud.] at least.

KANJI: All right. So you can check that out if you're interested on the CJPME website or Facebook page, I assume. Thank you so much for joining us, Grace.

BATCHOUN: My pleasure. Thank you for having me.

KANJI: And thank you for joining us on the Real News Network.

End

DISCLAIMER: Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.



Comments

Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at contact@therealnews.com

latest stories

Let's Make Real News!
Thousands of Black Lives Matter Activists Protest During the DNC
'Lesser of Two Evils' Argument Not Resonating with DNC Protestors
Donald Trump: The Raw and Naked Face of a System That Showers Speculators with Obscene Riches
Sanders Delegates Stage Walkout in Protest of Clinton Nomination
Green Party Candidate Jill Stein Draws Crowd of Hundreds After DNC Walkout
TRNN Livestream of DNC Day 2
What Will Sanders Delegates Do After Bernie's Call for Unity Behind Clinton?
Portia Boulger, Featured in Viral Video Viewed by Millions, Explains her Anger at DNC
Sanders Campaign Manager: Now is the Time to Keep Pushing
Sanders Delegate: Removal of Wasserman-Schultz Not Enough
Sanders Delegate: Political Revolution Can't End with Bernie
The European Revolt Against the Neoliberal EU (2/2)
Michelle Obama's Democractic convention speech
Elizabeth Warren: Democratic Convention Speech
Bernie Sanders at DNC
Baltimore's Tax System Takes From the Poor to Give to the Rich
The Empire Files: Bringing Corporations to Justice with Ecuador's UN Rep
The European Revolt Against the Neoliberal EU (1/2)
DNC Protesters Push into Convention Perimeter Demanding Their Voices be Heard
Bernie Delegate Network Press Conference
Bernie Sanders Supporters Booed Debbie Wasserman Schultz Off Convention Stage
Sanders Supporters React to Meeting with Sanders Ahead of his DNC Speech
Green Party Nominee Jill Stein Leads Rally Outside ‪DNC‬
Sanders supporters march on DNC
How Progressive is Elizabeth Warren?
Tariq Ali: Brexit and Migration
Turkey's Night of Long Knives
The Laura Flanders Show: Fighting Islamophobia & Education Apartheid
DNC - Protest Rally Day 1

TheRealNewsNetwork.com, RealNewsNetwork.com, The Real News Network, Real News Network, The Real News, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of Independent World Television inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and The Real News Network.

All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network. Click here for more

Problems with this site? Please let us know

Linux VPS Hosting by Star Dot Hosting