March 19, 2015

Report: Environmental Inequality Disproportionality Affects Black and Latino Communities

UMass-Amherst Researcher Klara Zwickl discusses measuring environmental inequality through industrial air pollution in the U.S. and recommends solutions to bridge economic disparities
Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here


Share to Facebook Share to Twitter

Supporting TRNN is a little like having my own television station. I can watch whatever I find interesting and at any time. I also enjoy the privilege of publishing my opinions on Disqus. - Gregory
Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


Klara Zwickl is a researcher at the Institute for Ecological Economics at the Vienna University of Economics and Business in Austria She is working on a research project on environmental inequality with Professors Michael Ash and James K. Boyce, and is currently visiting the Political Economy Research Institute at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and recently completed her PhD in Economics at the University of Massachusetts Amherst.


Report: Environmental Inequality Disproportionality Affects Black and Latino CommunitiesJESSICA DESVARIEUX, TRNN PRODUCER: Welcome to The Real News Network. I am Jessica Desvarieux in Baltimore.

A new report has been released measuring environmental inequality. Researchers looked at industrial air pollution exposure in the United States across all 50 states and compared exposure based on race and economics. The report is titled Three Measures of Environmental Inequality.

Now joining us is one of the authors of the report, Klara Zwickl. She is a postdoctoral researcher at the Institute for Ecological Economics at Vienna University in Austria. And she worked in tandem with the University of Massachusetts Amherst's Political Economy Research Institute on this report.

Thank you for joining us, Klara.


DESVARIEUX: So, Klara, your report measured environmental inequality. First of all, just define for us what that is. And how do you measure something like that?

ZWICKL: So, concerning the measurement here at PERI we are fortunate to have access to very high quality data on industrial air pollution exposure. So, for over 50 million tiny grid cells covering the entire United States, we have a measure of pollution exposure. And we combine these data with income and socioeconomic data also that define spatial resolution to look at who is disproportionately affected by pollution exposure. And--yeah. And we calculate some inequality measures based on these data, and we do all sorts of statistical analyses.

DESVARIEUX: Okay. So what did some of those statistical analysis--what came out of it? What were some of the most alarming findings?

ZWICKL: So, I mean, we find consistently that poor people and minorities are disproportionately affected by pollution exposure. And now we're doing studies, we're doing analysis at the national level. And you could say maybe these national-level results don't tell a lot about local disparities, because poor people and minorities generally lived in the more polluted regions of the country as a whole.

Now, when you then look at disparities only within cities or within regions, you find that the results hold, and in some cases they tend to be stronger. For example, this is especially true for Hispanics, who generally live in the cleaner parts of the country as a whole, like the Southwest. But within the regions and cities, they live in the more polluted neighborhoods. African-Americans, by contrast, both live in the more polluted regions, as well as in the more polluted neighborhoods within cities and regions.

DESVARIEUX: You also look specifically at industrial air pollution. What is special about industrial air pollution? And compare that to other environmental disparities.

ZWICKL: So, first of all what is important about air pollution is that it is a huge environmental health risk and that there's a growing understanding that it has been seriously underestimated in the past. According to a study by the World Health Organization, now one in eight global death are related to some form of air pollution. So they say that air pollution is now the world's largest single environmental health risk. And there are other studies by the International Monetary Fund or the European Commission largely confirming these findings.

So, now, industrial air pollution, the data we're having on the over hundreds of chemicals that are emitted from the toxic facilities only accounts for small part of this. But what is interesting about this is that it is, on the one hand, very unequally distributed, but this distribution is not something natural, but it's the outcome of political struggles and passed regulations, etc.

Now, clearly you'll have more air pollution from heating in places that are colder or you'll have more air pollution from cars and trucks in places with higher population density, and it's really hard to target these. But for industrial air pollution it's very easy, because you can, for example, include environmental justice considerations for the sighting of new facilities, or you can install scrubbers that filter out some of the most hazardous chemicals. And these things are sometimes very small changes for the firms, with huge positive impact for neighborhoods.

DESVARIEUX: Alright. And you've been able to do all this because you guys actually have the data on industrial air pollution. But there are other forms of pollution where we just don't have that kind of data. What would you need order to assess other forms of pollution?

ZWICKL: The data limitation is a serious problem. Some databases that the Environmental Protection Agency has on air pollution have not been updated for a very long time. Other databases just or, generally, greenhouse gas emissions and non-greenhouse gas emissions are not covered in the same databases, so you can not really address some really important research questions.

But there's an even more--there are some even more serious problems when it comes to disclosure, especially as far as new environmental hazards are concerned. So, for example, fracking. Fracking is exempt from the main environmental regulations in the United States, including laws on chemical disclosure. So what happened is that states that aim to regulate fracking--but unsurprisingly, now regulation varies strongly across states. Some states have very generous exemptions of disclosure for companies because companies can declare some chemicals they release as trade secrets. And in some states, timing of disclosure is very late. So what can happen is that neighborhoods are already exposed to pollutants for a significant time span before they actually learn about this.

DESVARIEUX: Klara, besides just getting more disclosure, what other policies would you recommend for the United States government to take in order to reduce environmental disparities?

ZWICKL: Well, we need to include distributional considerations into environmental policy and environmental considerations into economic and social policy. Currently, market-based environmental policy mechanisms such as emissions trading regimes are very popular amongst policymakers, and especially for reducing carbon emissions. And the rationale here is that for climate change, it doesn't matter where one unit of emissions takes place, because it has the same negative climate impact everywhere. So the rationale goes that basically emissions reductions should be achieved where it is easiest to do so and market forces are allowed to basically solve this in the most cost-efficient way.

Now, there is a serious problem with that. The burning of fossil fuels not only contributes to climate change, but it also pollutes the air locally. There's a growing literature on air-quality co-benefits of carbon reductions that recognizes this.

Now, if we do have other benefits from reducing carbon emissions, including improved air quality, then it really matters where emissions reductions are achieved. So distributional considerations become very important. And it's important to keep these in mind in environmental policy.

DESVARIEUX: Alright. Klara Zwickl, thank you so much for joining us.

ZWICKL: Thanks very much for the invitation.

DESVARIEUX: And thank you for joining us on The Real News Network.


DISCLAIMER: Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at

latest stories

Growing Discontent with Corruption Brings Thousands of Russians to the Streets
Will Dems Derail Sanders's Push for Public Option?
Arrest of Omar Barghouti Comes Amidst Upsurge in International Support for Boycott of Israel
Baltimore Mayor's Veto of $15/Hr Bill Shows Corporate Wing of Democrats Alive and Well
Military-Industrial Complex Pushes Nuke Modernization, Risking Confrontation with Russia
Empire Files: The Sikh Experience in America
Nebraskan Landowners Resist Keystone XL By Refusing to Sell Their Property to TransCanada
Study Links Extreme Weather Events to Climate Change
Sixth Year of War in Syria Marked by Tremendous Civilian Casualties
The Protest-Resignation of UN Under-Secretary Dr. Rima Khalaf
Climate Catastrophe Is Here: 2016 Hottest Year on Record
Millions for Prisoners Human Rights March in D.C. Set for August
"Wealthcare" Defeated: Health Care For All Back on the Agenda
Defending the Climate in the Age of Trump
Baltimore Public School Funding Pales in Comparison to Private Education Spending
Rattling the Bars: Women and Incarceration
Trump-Republican Alliance in Disarray?
Baltimore Mayor's Veto of $15 Wage Protects Policy of Subsidizing Wealthy, Councilperson Says
The Truth Behind the War on Immigrants
Were Haitian Police Behind Assassination Attempt on Aristide?
New Provisions Eliminate Healthcare From GOP 'Wealthcare' Bill
Why Further Revelations on Trump's Russian Connections Might Fail to Bring Him Down
18 Million U.S. Citizens Exposed to Lead-Contaminated Water Systems
Russia vs. USA: Who is the Threat, Who is the Aggressor? (2/2)
Should Sanders Continue the Fight Outside the Democratic Party?
Fed Inflation Target Keeping Wages Low, People Out of Jobs
Is Trump Dangerous for Russia?
Was the Georgian Conflict Started to Elect John McCain President in 2008? Pt.1
Will the NDP Adopt Pro-BDS Platform?
Massive Cuts to EPA Threaten Communities Already Suffering From Pollution, Climate Change,, The Real News Network, Real News Network, The Real News, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of Independent World Television inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and The Real News Network.

All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network. Click here for more

Problems with this site? Please let us know

Managed Wordpress Hosting