• Latest News
  • Pitch a Story
  • Work with a Journalist
  • Join the Blog Squad
  • Afghanistan
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Baltimore
  • Canada
  • Egypt
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • Middle East
  • Russia
  • Economy
  • Environment
  • Health Care
  • Military
  • Occupy
  • Organize This
  • Reality Asserts Itself
  • US Politics
  • Community Victory over Major Healthcare Corporation

    A community and labor coalition has just won a years-long battle against the largest private healthcare provider in San Francisco -   July 3, 13
    Members don't see ads. If you are a member, and you're seeing this appeal, click here

    Share to Facebook Share to Twitter

    Real News simply has no entertainment value. But its news value puts CNN,MSNBC,ABC& BBC to shame! - Santhip
    Log in and tell us why you support TRNN


    Joseph Smooke, a Producer on this story was Housing Director then Executive Director of Bernal Heights Neighborhood Center, a lead organization in the Save St. Luke's coalition and the Coalition for Health Planning San Francisco


    Community Victory over Major Healthcare CorporationDYAN RUIZ, TRNN PRODUCER: Community organizations and labor in San Francisco have just won a years-long battle against the largest private health-care provider in the city. Their victory against the odds could serve as a model for other communities battling huge corporations. One the one side, there's California Pacific Medical Centre, the most profitable health-care corporation in San Francisco. They wanted to build a new, centrally located mega-hospital that would meet new earthquake requirements. On the other side, a labor-community coalition fighting to ensure quality health services in and for marginalized communities.

    GORDON MAR, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, JOBS WITH JUSTICE: I think the coalition really saw that CPMC was really no different than other big powerful corporations, self-serving corporations, from WalMart to the big banks.

    PAUL KUMAR, CONSULTANT, NATIONAL UNION OF HEALTH CARE WORKERS: And it would take a monumental effort to get them to approach the San Francisco health-care market in a different way.

    BOB PRENTICE, FORMER DIRECTOR, BAY AREA REGIONAL HEALTH INEQUITIES INITIATIVE AND REPRESENTATIVE ON CITYWIDE PANEL ON ST. LUKE'S, BERNAL HEIGHTS NEIGHBORHOOD CENTER: It was a matter of insisting that if CPMC wanted to carry out their business plan, they had to do it in a way that would serve all of San Francisco. So it became a big fight for social justice.

    RUIZ: Many have criticized California Pacific Medical Center for prioritizing profits over the health-care needs of San Francisco's marginalized communities.

    PRENTICE: There was a time when a health-care system in a city like San Francisco would be subject to some kind of a planning oversight. But that period disappeared in the Reagan era, and decisions started to be left up to the market.

    DAVID CAMPOS, SAN FRANCISCO BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, DISTRICT 9: The big difference in Northern California is that you have a larger number of beds that are controlled by one entity, and that is Sutter. And that, because of that, that has led to health-care costs being higher in Northern California, significantly higher, than they are in Southern California.

    NATO GREEN, FORMER UNION REP, CALIFORNIA NURSES ASSOCIATION: Sutter, CPMC's parent corporation, would report, year after year, five hundred, six hundred million dollars in profit.

    RUIZ: Ironically, it was CPMC's anti-competitive practices that put them in control of an important charity care hospital, St. Luke's. St. Luke's accused CPMC of skimming insured patients and filed an anti-trust lawsuit. The settlement resulted in an unexpected twist: CPMC agreed to support St. Luke's core services, including inpatient care. St. Luke's later became part of CPMC. Since taking over the hospital, CPMC had constant battles with the California Nurses Association, including fighting over who pays for health-care benefits.

    GREEN: The way that they cut health benefits to nurses was particularly incredible because they were a health-care company employing nurses, and they wanted to make nurses pay more to get health care from them.

    RUIZ: Community groups and labor organized in coalition against CPMC when they came out with their Institutional Master Plan in 2008. It included building a 555-bed hospital with specialized services and a medical office building at Van Ness and Geary on Cathedral Hill. Hospitals had to meet new earthquake safety requirements. CPMC wanted to build new facilities instead of retrofitting their existing hospitals.

    PRENTICE: They were going to close inpatient care at the Pacific campus. They were going to close the California campus altogether. And consistent with that, they were going to close inpatient care at St. Luke's and argue that all inpatient care will now occur at this highly specialized hospital at Van Ness and Geary.

    RUIZ: One of the major issues that community and labor groups were concerned about was the closure of St. Luke's.

    PRENTICE: St Luke's is the only private nonprofit hospital in the southeastern half of the city. If you think about some of the neighborhoods that that means, it's like Bayview Hunters Point, it's Bernal, it's Mission, it's Excelsior, it's Ingleside. You know. Apnd who lives in those neighborhoods?

    DEANNE LIU, CORE LEADER, CHINESE PROGRESSIVE ASSOCIATION, YOUTH MOJO: I have been outreaching in the Excelsior neighborhood for about three years now, and I do spend a lot of time there, so what I see is that I do notice a lot of people of color. There's been a lot of people who are not insured or they have inadequate health care.

    TELESFORE UNITE, BAYVIEW RESIDENT AND LEADER, BERNAL HEIGHTS NEIGHBORHOOD CENTER: Most people really go to St. Luke's in this area. They don't ask so much as long as you have your Medicare, Medi-Cal and it's okay.

    PRENTICE: People who live in Bayview Hunters Point can expect to live on average fourteen years less than people who live on Russian Hill. You're talking about two neighborhoods in the same city. And how do you explain that difference? And it is so tied to people's day-to-day living conditions, everything from the physical environment of their neighborhood to the history of racism and how decisions got made about who lives where and what else is part of that way of life, from ports and railroads and freeways and power plants and sewage treatment plants. So that's the large sense of what health equity is. Within that there is also the question about who has access to health care.

    RUIZ: If services at St. Luke's charity care hospital were to close, then poor and uninsured patients would have little choice but to access San Francisco's public health facility, SF General. But with no citywide health planning, some services at SF General, like inpatient psychiatric units that were being shut down at St. Luke's, might not have the capacity to absorb additional patients. Those patients would likely end up in the public health system's emergency care, or the public health system would have to increase services at a cost to taxpayers.

    GREEN: What we discovered was that on the way to CPMC trying to close St. Luke's outright that it really felt like death by a thousand cuts, that they were continually undermining the hospital and making it less of a viable hospital, so that when they hit the five-year mark and completed their commitment, they can say, see, this isn't a functional hospital; we need to abandon it."

    RUIZ: When the development plan to build a new facility on Cathedral Hill became public, groups throughout the city started mobilizing against the plan. Two coalitions consisting of community groups and labor joined forces to stand up for the needs of workers and marginalized communities.

    GREEN: There was a labor issue; there was a health-care issue in terms of access to services. It was a business plan that affected five different neighborhoods. It affected housing, it affected transit, it affected city services, it affected taxpayers, it affected other hospitals. And so there was something for everyone to hate.

    JAMES TRACY, GOOD NEIGHBOR COALITION: When we talk about the ideal of community and labor working together for progressive social change, that's a wonderful goal. But we all know that it's really hard to maintain.

    RUIZ: Most of the members of the coalition were nonprofit community-based organizations, and they were going against the huge resources of CPMC Sutter. The groups also had to learn how hospitals do business to understand what CPMC was telling the public.

    GREEN: They spent years hiring one consulting group after another and marketing firm and pouring enormous sums of money into advertising and publicity stunts and bringing men in suits to hearings who would throw down reams of paper on tables and say, this proves that we're right and you should give us whatever we want.

    PRENTICE: This was going to be a huge development--a big hospital on one of the busiest intersections in the city, a medical office building across Van Ness Avenue with a tunnel underneath, a parking garage. They were going to also become the largest private employer in San Francisco. So these were, like, huge stakes, and the leverage we had was the development proposal, was the city's authority to approve or amend a plan for development.

    RUIZ: The land use approval process became the public's forum for speaking out on issues such as health care, employment, housing, and transit. In San Francisco, development proposals of this scale ultimately end up at the Board of Supervisors for a final decision.

    LEE: So one of the demands that the coalition was pushing for was that any agreement between St. Luke's has to have a plan for the viability and sustainability of St. Luke's for the long term.

    GREEN: The way private non-profit hospitals work when they are going to be a safety net hospital is that they tend to have a variety of services that lose money, like an emergency room, that meet the health-care needs of a community, and that is offset by having some profit center. Usually it's some type of surgery that they do that is for insured patients. And we said we want St. Luke's to have an anchor. We don't want it to just be the least amount of hospital that you need to support an emergency room. We want it to have something like neurosciences that will make it a viable hospital.

    RUIZ: Despite the coalition pushing back, CPMC kept pushing their development plan forward. A critical moment came in spring 2012 when the Board of Supervisors did not approve the plan.

    MAR: Because of the successful work of our coalition in presenting a broad unified platform and a broad coalition, we were able to win over the support of a majority on the Board of Supervisors to say that that deal was not good enough. And that really forced CPMC to come back to the table to renegotiate a new deal. Bt this time it wasn't just with the mayor's office at the table, which it had been up till that point, but now, beginning in the fall of 2012, the new round of negotiations included three representatives--three members of the Board of Supervisors.

    RUIZ: Early this year, Supervisors Chiu, Farrell, and Campos worked with Mayor Lee and brought in a mediator, Lou Giraudo. Out of those sessions, a final development deal significantly different from the original was struck. Despite repeated attempts, CPMC Sutter Health declined an interview for this story with The Real News Network. Here's CPMC's CEO presenting the latest proposal.

    WARREN S. BROWNER, CPMC CEO: Our proposed new health-care facilities are different from one we presented to the Planning Commission last year. They fit well with the future of health-care and future population growth in San Francisco. The Cathedral Hill campus, while smaller than our proposal last year, will still be our largest campus. We look forward to serving patients from throughout San Francisco at this new, centrally located facility. In addition, we recognize that the demographics of San Francisco are changing and that more families are living and working south of Market. Our revised plan with a larger hospital at St. Luke's campus reflects the changing demographics of the city.

    RUIZ: The new development proposal was unanimously approved on June 25 by the Board of Supervisors. This version includes many of the coalition's demands. Most significantly, the new Cathedral Hill hospital will be close to 50 percent smaller and St. Luke's hospital will be 50 percent larger than originally proposed.

    GREEN: It was supposed to be closed by 2009, and it's 2013, and not only is it still open, but CPMC is going to be investing $300 million in rebuilding it.

    RUIZ: Shortly after the new development agreement was announced this spring, CPMC agreed to fair contracts with the California Nurses Association and the National Union of Healthcare Workers.

    CAMPOS: This outcome and this project is an example of how coalitions, in this case of community and labor, can truly make a difference, can truly lead to an outcome that no one thought was possible.

    RUIZ: People are now saying that if CPMC actually built the development they initially wanted, they would have sunk massive amounts of money into a project that was financially unsustainable, especially given the implementation of the Affordable Care Act. The Act changes the way people are insured and the amount paid for services. So the amount of revenue CPMC could expect from the proposed huge, highly specialized facility is far less than before.

    PRENTICE: In fact, the mediator even said to the folks in the coalition at one point, you know, I think you guys might have done them a favor.

    KUMAR: The community coalition, however badly despised we might have been by various elements in CPMC and Sutter Health, had actually saved Sutter Health from itself.

    LEE: I think now we're trying to figure out, well, what does accountability look like, what do we need to do to make sure that it just doesn't look good on paper but it actually happens in the right way and it happens with the community input and process. So I think that's kind of getting figured out right now is what does accountability and monitoring look like and enforcement of the terms of the development agreement. But I think overall we feel really excited about that we can say that, yeah, St. Luke's is going to be around for the long term.

    RUIZ: The victory for the labor community coalition not only saved a critical hospital serving marginalized communities in San Francisco; the new plan will also ensure employment opportunities, new affordable housing, and was a huge step forward for CPMC's relationship with its unions. In the end, the years-long struggle will benefit not only the communities represented in the coalition, but all San Franciscans for decades to come.

    This is Dyan Ruiz for The Real News Network.

    Joseph Smooke, a producer on this story, was housing director, then executive director of Bernal Heights Neighborhood Center, a lead organization in the Save St. Luke's coalition and the Coalition for Health Planning San Francisco.


    DISCLAIMER: Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete accuracy.


    Our automatic spam filter blocks comments with multiple links and multiple users using the same IP address. Please make thoughtful comments with minimal links using only one user name. If you think your comment has been mistakenly removed please email us at


    Latest Stories

    The Bundy Ranch Standoff Demonstrates Values Shared by Corporations and the Far Right
    The Resegregation of American Schools
    The Modern History of Venezuela, Why Still So Much Crime? - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (7/9)
    What Role Has Russia Played in Eastern Ukraine?
    Can Johns Hopkins Afford to Pay A Living Wage? (2/2)
    University Sit-In Targets World's Largest Private Coal Company
    The Modern History of Venezuela and the Need for a Post-Oil Economy - Edgardo Lander on RAI (6/9)
    Can Johns Hopkins Afford to Pay A Living Wage? (1/2)
    One Percent of Environmentalists Killings Lead to Convictions
    Investigation Finds Former Ukraine President Not Responsible For Sniper Attack on Protestors
    The Modern History of Venezuela from 1973 to the Caracazo Massacre - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (3/9)
    Ukraine Transitional Gov't Moves Militarily To Reclaim Seized Buildings
    IPCC Report Flawed By Narrow Focus on Carbon Emissions
    The Modern History of Venezuela: The Bolivarian Revolution - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (5/9)
    Obama Signs Directives to Reduce the Gender Wage Gap
    Eastern Ukraine Lacks Political Representation in Kiev
    Demystifying the Role of Mitigation in the Most Recent IPCC Report
    Hypersurveillance State Won't Prevent Another Boston Marathon Bombing
    The Modern History of Venezuela from 1973 to the Caracazo Massacre - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (3/9)
    Univ. of Maine Faculty Reinstated After Students Protest Against Cuts
    The Modern History of Venezuela from 1908 to 1973 - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (2/9)
    IMF Will Address Global Inequality, Says Managing Director Christine Lagarde
    Raising Big Banks' Leverage Ratio Good, But Not Nearly Enough
    TRNN Replay: Austerity Road to 19th Century
    Has Palestinian Maneuvering Revived Peace Talks?
    Late Jackson Mayor Lumumba's Son Wins Primary to Replace His Father, Runoff Election Ahead
    Quebecers Reject PQ and Elect a Liberal Government Representing Big Business
    TRNN Debate: Decriminalization vs. Legalization
    The Beginning of the Chavez Era - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (4/9)
    "Off With His Head": Court Upholds Obama's Power to Kill
    Workers at Nation's Top Hospital Strike For Fair Wages
    From Exile to Radicalization in Venezuela - Edgardo Lander on Reality Asserts Itself (1/9)
    Rwanda 20 Years Later: Genocide, Western Plunder of Congo, and President Kagame
    Ukrainian Protesters in the East Demand More Autonomy From Kiev Government
    Hunger Strikers Demand President Obama Halt His Record 2 Million Deportations
    Indian Parliamentary Elections - A Primer With Vijay Prashad
    West Looks to Carve Up Ukraine & Privatize Industries Held by Kleptocrats
    Where Are Israeli-Palestinian Peace Negotiations Headed?
    The Multiple Kingdoms of Saudi Arabia (5/5)
    Do the Afghan Presidential Elections Signify Progress?
    Republican Presidential Hopefuls Pay Homage to Billionaire Casino Tycoon Sheldon Adelson
    Will Extremist Lieberman Become Israel's Next Prime Minister?
    Why do the Saudis Want the US to Attack Iran? (4/5)
    Immigrant Advocates and Families Tell President Obama 'Not One More'
    Elections, Pipelines, and Protests - The Canada Panel
    Chris Hedges on "Israel's War on American Universities"
    Baltimore Residents Decry Lack of Affordable Housing
    Yellen Talks the Talk But Will She Walk the Walk?
    Hopkins Hospital Workers Speak Out against "Poverty Wages"
    Will Venezuela's New Floating Exchange Rate Curb Inflation?
    The European Central Bank's War on Wages is Pushing Europe's Economy to the Brink
    Supreme Court Decision Opens Floodgates for More Campaign Cash
    Charles Keating, the Financier Behind the Savings and Loan Scandal, Dies at 90
    Saudi Arabia and the al-Qaeda Monster (3/5)
    Maryland Residents Voice Opposition to Natural Gas Fracking Export Facility
    Supreme Court Ruling Gives Wealthy Individuals More Influence Over Elections
    What are the Saudis Afraid Of? - Madawi Al-Rasheed (2/5)
    Baltimore's MICA Adjunct Professors Set to Vote on Unionization
    Boycott of Israel Moving to Next Level?
    Hypocrisy Dressed Up as "Realism" Justifies American Alliance with Saudi Dictatorship
    Immigration Reform in the Shadows of Cesar Chavez's Legacy
    Leaked Senate Report Shows Use of Torture As "Ineffective"
    UN Report Says Climate Change Will Threaten Food Production Worldwide
    The Hypocrisy of US Calling for Enforcement of International Law
    How the Ecuadorian Economy Grew in a Global Recession
    'Shadows of Liberty' Trailer
    Kristina Borjesson on Why CBS Shut Down Her investigation into Flight 800 (2/8)
    Glen Ford on Racism in the American Media (3/8)
    Paul Jay on What Drives Corporate Media and What Drive The Real News (4/8)
    Creating a New Media Paradigm After Citizens United (5/8)
    Should The Left Engage with the Mainstream Media? (6/8)
    What Is the Financial Backing For The Real News? (7/8)
    Standing up to Character Assassination (8/8)
    Oligarchs, Fascists and the People's Protest in Ukraine
    TRNN Debate: Is Obamacare In the Interest of Workers?
    Too-Big-To-Fail Advantage Remains Intact For Big Banks
    Obama and the Saudi Agenda
    TRNN Replay: Investigating the Saudi Government's 9/11 Connection and the Path to Disilliusionment - Sen. Graham on Reality Asserts Itself pt 1
    The Iraq War's Real Legacy
    Petitions with 100,000+ Signatures Call for Snowden's Passport to be Reinstated
    We Need to Harness People Power - Andy Shallal on Reality Asserts Itself (4/4)
    BC Pipeline Fight and Quebec Elections - The Canada Panel
    Jonathan Schell - 1943-2014: Board Member of TRNN on Why We Need The Real News
    Teachers on Strike from the UK to Argentina
    Connecticut Poised to Become First State with $10.10 Minimum Wage
    Oil Spill Threatens Wildlife and Local Economy
    DC School Test Scores Up, But Poor Black Kids Are Doing Worse - Andy Shallal on RAI (3/4)
    Obama's Proposal To End NSA Bulk Data Collection Won't Protect Privacy
    How Google, Apple & The Biggest Tech Companies Colluded to Fix Workers' Wages
    An American Should be One that Questions Their Government - Andy Shallal on RAI (2/4)
    What's Driving Putin & Obama's Posturing on Ukraine?
    Hundreds of Students & Faculty Occupy College Campus to Fight Cuts to Public Higher Ed
    Due Process 'Impossible' In Harsh Death Sentencing Of Over 500 Muslim Brotherhood Members
    Has Anglo-American Capitalism Run Out of Steam?
    Being the "Other" in America - Andy Shallal on Reality Asserts Itself (1/4)
    TRNN Debate: Should Baltimore 'Ban The Box'?
    How Fallujah Became the Iraqi Government's New Battleground
    Why I Decided to Blow the Whistle on the NSA
    NASA Climate Predictions Show Serious Threat To Humanity
    Professor Who Teaches Israel-Palestine Conflict Accuses College of Violating His Academic Freedom
    CIA and NSA Wrongdoing Requires Independent Investigation, Says Former Church Committee Staff
    Are Tuition Breaks Enough To Combat High Student Debt And Low Graduation Rates?
    Industries Across the U.S. Are Stealing Wages From Their Lowest Paid Workers
    Who In Ukraine Will Benefit From An IMF Bailout?
    NSA Recording All International Calls From U.S.
    Israel "Making Lives Miserable" for Africans, Hoping They 'Self-Deport' (2/2)
    BP Gets Green Light to Drill in Gulf, But Has Safety Improved?
    Residents Still Not Drinking Tap Water Two Months After West Virginia Spill (1/2)
    Libya's Descent Into Turmoil Three Years After NATO Intervention
    From Pipelines to Peladeau - Canadian Report
    Israel "Making Lives Miserable" for Africans, Hoping They 'Self-Deport' (1/2)
    Congressional Progressive Caucus Budget Strikes Back Against Austerity
    Libya Three Years Later - Chaos and Partition
    Why Was Gaddafi Overthrown?
    Should Ukraine and West Accept De Facto Crimea Joining Russia? (2/2)
    Tony Benn Saw Socialism as the Culmination of Democratization
    Why Didn't Bush/Cheney Attack Iran and Can Obama Make and Sell a Deal? - Gareth Porter on Reality Asserts Itself (3/3)
    After Late Mayor Lumumba is Laid to Rest, What's Next for Jackson, Mississippi? (2/2)
    Crimea Referendum: Self Determination or Big Power Manipulation? (1/2)
    Sen. Graham: President Must Side with Openness About CIA and 9/11
    Manufacturing a Narrative for War - Gareth Porter on Reality Asserts Itself (2/3)
    Protesters Hit the Streets of Brooklyn to Demand $15 Minimum Wage
    Hammer: 'Moral Bankruptcy' Behind Massive GM Recall
    White House Withholds Thousands of Documents from Senate CIA Probe
    I Grew Up Believing in Time Magazine's Version of America - Gareth Porter on RAI (1/3)
    Western European Banks Vulnerable to Ukrainian Sovereign Debt Crisis
    TRNN Debate: What's Driving Inflation in Venezuela? (2/2)
    CIA vs. Senate: Who Is Obama Protecting?
    Will Tipped Workers Get Excluded Again From Minimum Wage Hike?
    TRNN Debate: What's Driving Inflation in Venezuela? (1/2)
    After Late Mayor Lumumba is Laid to Rest, What's Next for Jackson, Mississippi?(1/2)
    TRNN Replay: A Look at Who's Poised to Become No.2 at the Fed
    How Right-Wing Nationalism Rose to Influence in Ukraine (2/2)
    Netanyahu Attacks Boycott As Campaign Enters New Phase
    Moving Towards a Police State - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (7/7)
    Fighting Reagan's Secret, Illegal Wars - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (6/7)
    Puerto Rican Independence Movement and Cuba Further Radicalized Me - Michael Ratner on RAI (5/7)
    The Butcher of Attica - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (4/7)
    MLK and a Radicalizing Moment in American History - Michael Ratner on Reality Asserts Itself (3/7), Real News Network, Real News, Real News For Real People, IWT are trademarks and service marks of IWT.TV inc. "The Real News" is the flagship show of IWT and Real News Network.

    All original content on this site is copyright of The Real News Network.  Click here for more

    Problems with this site? Please let us know

    Linux VPS Hosting by Star Dot Hosting